Back to Message Board

John Devenney

Hello. My name is John Devenney. I live in Devon, Pennsylvania, USA. I am trying to did deeper into my heritage and am running in some confusing data. As far as I was concerned, I was essentiallyIrish with perhaps a smattering of German( Surnames: F: Devenney, M: Cotter, MGM: Mullen, MGF: Cotter, PGM: Lion, PGF: Devenney).

However DNA analysis from Family Tree,Living DNA and Ancestry DNA suggestedsomethingsurprisingly different: 58%English, 20% Scottish,6.5 %Northern Ireland, 6.4% Irish,6.4% Scandinavia and 4.8% Wales.

My Y-Haplogroup is R-FGC20324 and my mtDNA is U5a1c1. When I tried to match up my STRs with the Western Irish Modal and the Super Western Atlantic Modal and finally with a Canadian Irish Academic named Devanney, my STRs didnt come close. When I looked at the Y-500 SNPs, my exact and/or closematches didnt have any names even remotely Irish. SNPs that I did findsomewhat interesting were U106(Anglo/Saxon), Z-381(a French connection) and L48(referred to as the scientist gene). The question that I have is Are there 2Devenney lines,an Irish line and an English/ Scot Irish line? Would welcome your input. John

Jdevenne@gmail.com

7 replies

John:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

How far back have you gone with your family tree? Have you identified one or more ancestors who were born in Ireland? If you have any information, names and dates, we can try to see if we can locate any church or civil records.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

John,

I’d take most DNA ethnicity analysis with a pinch of salt. Mostly harmless entertainment, and about as accurate as a horoscope. According to the London Times on 16th June 2019, Professor Mark Thomas from University College London said: “Ethnicity is a socially constructed category, not a genetic one. Genetic tests cannot assign an ethnicity unless people start to construct ethnicities on the basis of genetic tests. They can identify genetic clusters in modern populations and compare your genes to the different clusters but there’s very little ancestry inference in that. It doesn’t mean it’s where your genes come from.”

DNA testing also seems to assume that people never moved. There has been so much internal migration around Britain & Ireland in the past 4000 years as to make a DNA breakdown between Irish, Welsh, Scots, English etc pretty meaningless, especially when you go back several hundred years. Most of the population all share a common Brythonic origin ie they are descended from people who migrated north through France as the last ice age retreated. When they got to Britain they swarmed around everywhere. Some moved north to Scotland, some west to Wales. And many continued to move after that for military, economic and cultural reasons. Though southern England has been inhabited for 400,000 years, Ireland has only been inhabited for about 8000 years. Most of its early settlers came from Britain. Then many Irish moved to Scotland, notably around 495AD when the kingdom of Dalriada was established by the Scotiae tribe from Co. Antrim, who gave Scotland it’s name, and who ruled Scotland and part of Ulster. So Scotland is named after an invading Irish tribe who came in sufficiently large numbers to be able to rename the country and to introduce their own language, ie gaelic. In the 1600s, 200,000 Scots and a large number of English and Welsh moved to Ireland as a part of the Plantation of Ireland and also because of a severe famine in Scotland in the late 1600s. From the 1800s they were moving back from Ireland to Britain in hundreds of thousands because the employment prospects were better there. Therefore the idea of the Irish and the Welsh, Scots & English being distinct ethnic groups for DNA purposes is basically just daft (in my opinion).

So most of the population of Ireland shares common DNA with people in England, Wales & Scotland. Trying to draw a distinction between the two is therefore is probably dodgy science. At the closest point it’s 13 miles from Ireland to Scotland. Waves of people have been going back and forth between Scotland & Ireland since the end of the last ice age. The genes and DNA of the peoples of Ireland and Scotland must be so closely related no scientific test can really determine separate ethnicity. (DNA is good for lots of other aspects of ancestry though).

Having said all that Devenney (and it’s many variant spellings) is a common name in the north of Ireland. It wouldn’t be surprising if your ancestors came from there. (I can see about 2000 people of that surname in the 1901 Irish census). You can see where the surname was most common in Ireland in the mid 1800s using this website:

https://www.johngrenham.com/surnames/

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

 

 

Thank you Elwyn for your in-depth and thoughtful comments.  Your explanation makes a lot of sense  

Sadly, I can’t seem to nail down even rudimentary information such as where Michael Devenney(GGF; B: approx 1861 in Ireland) and Patrick( GGGF; B: approx 1841 in Ireland) were born and raised because there appear to be so many people with the names Michael and Patrick Devenney on theses databases. 

I will definitely however look up that website to see if I can get any further clarity.

John

 

 

Jdevenne@gmail.com

Thank you Roger for your offer to help.

So far, the best that I can come up with are approximate birthdates of Michael( B: approx. 1861) and Patrick((B: approx 1841) born somewhere in Ireland.  I would be happy to send you an photo attachment of the rest of the tree including my Mullen, Cotter, Montgomery and Lion ancestors if that would be of use. Do you have an email address that I could attach it to ?

John

 

Jdevenne@gmail.com

John:

We prefer keeping all correspondence on the bulletin board. It allows other volunteers to also comment on the message thread.

Regarding Michael Devenny born around 1861 with father Patrick, there are some good leads on the subscription site Roots Ireland. Do you know his mother's maiden name?

By the way, I grew up in North Philadelphia.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

 

 

Roger

Agree completely.  The more people who see it, the better the chances are of digging deeper. I’ll check out roots Ireland.  

How in the world did you get from North Philadelphia to Castlemore Roscommon ?

John

 

 

 

Jdevenne@gmail.com

John:

I live in Maryland now. My grandmother came from Castlemore parish when she emigrated to Philadelphia in 1906. If Michael and/or Patrick died in Pennsylvania from 1906-1964, Ancestry.com should have the death record and it possibly would have parents names.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.