Robyn:
Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!
I searched on Roots Ireland for a baptismal record for John with the parents names you provided and got no record.
The 1864 Griffiths Valuation for Co. Armagh showed two James Cregan records in Loughall civil parish. Did the parents come over pre-1864?
http://www.failteromhat.com/griffiths/armagh/loughgall.htm
Loughall RC baptismal records start in 1834 so possibly John was born before 1834 and a record is not available.
Have you considered autosomal DNA testing?
We also have an XO Chronicles site where you can post your ancestors stories.
Roger McDonnell