Back to Message Board

John Costello and Mary Wynn

I am looking to find more information on my great-great grandparents John Costello (born about 1819) and Mary Wynn (born about 1824) both in Ireland. They were both born in Ireland and immigrated to the US by January 1845 when they were married in Vermont. I presume they first immigrated to Canada and then went on to the US since they were married in St. Alban's, not far from the border. They had 10 children: Ann Maria, August 1846, Connecticut; Mary Jane, August 1847, Connecticut; Hannah Josephine, November 1848, Massachusetts; Thomas Ambrose, June 1850, Pennsylvania; John Francis, January 1852, New York; James Henry, April 1853, New York; Mary Ellen, December 1854, New York; Frances Emma, Feb 1856, New York; George Emmett, October 1858, New York; Samuel Paul, August 1861, Pennsylvania.

I do not have any information on where they were from other than family legend saying the Costellos were from County Mayo. I know nothing of them prior to 1845 when they arrive in America. I do not know of any siblings/parents for John. I have a Civil War Widow's Pension document Mary completed which has a Carl Wynn and P.R. Wynn who signed as witnesses and may be brothers or other relatives. They family eventually settles in Pittsburgh, PA after moving around a lot.

Thanks in advance!

IrelandXO member

3 replies

meganpriore:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

I did 10 year searches in Roots Ireland for John Costello and Mary Wynn. I tried an Ireland search and there were over 50 John Costello baptismal records but none in Mayo and there were 18 Mary Wynn records but none in Mayo. In general most Mayo RC parishes have records starting much later 1840s or later. Not having their parents names further complicates the search.

You may want to consider autosomal DNA testing. Possibly you will match someone with more info on your Costello and Wynn families.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Hi Roger!  Thanks for your help!  My dad has done the AncestryDNA test but it seems hard to pinpoint how you're related unless you've already both researched your family trees back far enough.  Perhaps we need to do a different test or upload the raw data to another site.

IrelandXO member

I have tested with Ancestry and Family Tree DNA and find Family Tree to be much better. They have better analytical tools. You may want to upload your Dad's raw DNA data to www.gedmatch.com  Gedmatch is a volunteer run site which takes data from all three testing companies. It will allow you to see if you have matches with someone who tested with Family Tree or 23 and Me (and also uploaded their data to Gedmatch). Gedmatch also has very good analytical tools.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.