tmg123:
Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!
I was unsuccessful trying to find the marriage record for James and Catherine, the baptismal record for Honorah or the marriage record for Honorah and John O'Brien. I looked on two different data bases. There are about five RC parishes with records starting later than 1843 so perhaps your family was from one of those parishes.
I looked at the 1850 Co. Limerick Griffiths Valuation head of household listing for a James Toohey and there were no records but there were four James Tuohy records. The details are below. Perhaps one of the four is for your ancestor.
Roger McDonnell
SourceSurnameFirst NameTownlandParishCounty Griffith
TouhyJamesClogh EastCroaghCo. LimerickGriffith
TuohyJamesGooigStradballyCo. LimerickGriffith
TuohyJamesPriors-Land (New Road)KilleelyCo. LimerickGriffith
TuohyJamesThomastownKilbreedy-MinorCo. Limerick