Clare,
I posted the following to another thread on this site, also concerning a Carroll/Kearns marriage:
Dear Mary,
I’m writing because coincidences between your questions and my family seem oddly strong.
I am the great-great grandson of Dennis Carroll and Catherine Kearns. I know nothing of their background except they were both born in Ireland and had thier first child, my great-grandfather William, in Haverstraw, New York, in1844, Census data suggest Dennis was born around 1802 and Catherine around 1816. Their ages would seem to make them contemporaries of Luke and Mary. So, same last name, same country of birth, same approximate ages. Very tempting to think there’s a link.
Also, one last coincidence: One of my DNA relatives in the Carroll/Kearns line is a young Canadian woman named Caitlin Kehoe. Until they arrived on this side of the Atlantic, she said, the family spelled the name Keogh.
If any of this rings any bells, please let me know. Cordially, Drew Fetherston