Back to Message Board

James Algeo of Ballymore

I am researching James Algeo of Ballymore (c.1839 - 1923). On his marriage cert (1864), it states that he married a spinster Eliza Miliken. But on the birth certificates of some of his children, the mother's name is given as Eliza Moffitt!! An Adam Moffitt was a witness on the marriage cert. I am totally confused. I can't find a previous marriage for Eliza (assuming she was a widow, not a spinster on her marriage to James Algeo). I can't find a baptismal cert for her either (assuming she had a stepfather and also used his name). Help!

Anna Jane

7 replies

Anna Jane,

If Eliza said she was a spinster on the marriage certificate, then I’d favour the step-father or step-mother explanation. One spouse being named Moffitt and the other Milliken. She might have then been known by both names (though usually where that happens both are mentioned on the marriage certificate, eg "Eliza Milliken otherwise Moffitt."). What denomination was Eliza before she married and what was her townland?

Did you notice that an Alexander Moffitt and an Amelia  Algeo are on the same page of Donegal marriages as Eliza Milliken? So they could well have married on the same day.  I wonder if that’s a coincidence or a connection? A double wedding of brother & sister Algeos. And the sister perhaps to a Moffitt? (You would need to order the cert to find out more).

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Hi Anna Jane!

I started working on your message about four hours ago but had to step away and I figured that Elwyn would provide you advice in the interim. I located the church marriage record transcription on Roots Ireland. The marriage took place at the Clondahorky East Church of Ireland parish. Both families lived in the civil parish of Clondahorky.

The baptismal records on Roots Ireland for children of James Algeo start in 1871 which would point to Elizabeth Milliken dying somewhere between 1864 and 1871 but I did not find a civil death index record for an Elizabeth Algeo in Co. Donegal nor did I locate a later marriage record for James Algeo on www.irishgenealogy.ie or on Roots Ireland. Strange!!

Roger McDonnell

Date of Marriage:18-Feb-1864
Parish / District:CLONDAHORKY EAST
County:Co. Donegal

Husband  JamesAlgeo Address Faugher Age Full Age (over 21)
Wife ElizaMilikenAddress:Ballymore Age 20
Denomination:Church Of Ireland
Husband's Father   ThomasAlgeo
Wife's Father JohnMiliken

Witness 1 Henry Algeo

Witness 2 Adam Milliken

 

 

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Anna Jane:

One other point. The 1857 Griffiths Valuation head of household listing for Clondahorky parish  http://www.failteromhat.com/griffiths/donegal/clondahorky.htm     does not show any Milliken records but does show a number of Moffett records including some in Ballymore which was the townland for Eliza Milliken? Maybe there were some mistakes with the surname on the records??

Roger

http://www.failteromhat.com/griffiths/donegal/clondahorky.htm

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

There are 2 Church of Ireland churches in Clondahorkey. One in Clondahorkey and another at Dunfanaghy. My guide to Church of Ireland records indicates that their baptisms start in 1756 and that the Rector/Vicar holds them. It also says “some coverage on rootsireland.”  It doesn’t say what years are on rootsireland. But if you can’t find a baptism ion-line it might be worth writing to the parish to see if they can help. (There may be a fee for that).

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Anna Jane/Elwyn:

I just checked Roots Ireland and their Clondahorky East Churxh of Ireland records start in 1870 so that explains why no baptismal records from 1864-1870. The Dunfanaghy C of I baptismal records start in 1872 (on Roots). 

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Many thanks for all your help and suggestions. What stood out for me was that on the civil marriage cert it was Adam MOFFITT as witness and on the church transcript it was Adam MILLIKEN. I'll keep digging.

Anna Jane

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.