I have had a look for Ballynagarrick but I can?t find a townland of that name in Ireland, let alone in Co Antrim. Townlands names were often mis-spelled in official documents and I have looked for something that sounds like it but cannot see anything fits well enough. That?s a great pity because having the townland name would make a huge difference to your search.
Regarding the name Orr, where it appears in the middle of a name like that, it often tells you the person?s mother?s maiden name. That was a common Scottish and Ulster Scots tradition.
Hampton is not a common name in Co Antrim. There?s only about 30 in the county in the 1901 census, nearly all in Belfast. Mostly Church of Ireland (which fits with David becoming an Anglican priest). 250 Hamptons in Ireland in that census.
3052 Orrs in Ireland the 1901 census. 864 in Co Antrim, spread all over the county. A mix of Presbyterians and Church of Ireland.
Statutory marriage registration started in Ireland (for non RC marriages) in April 1845. Since David Orr Hampton was born c 1841 his parents marriage should pre-date that. So you have to rely on church records for both the marriage and for his baptism. Tradition would be to marry in the bride?s church so it?s where she came from, and her denomination, that tells you where to search for any Hampton-Orr marriage. After the marriage she?d normally attend her husband?s church, so the children may not be baptised in the same church as the marriage.
The parish system relates largely to religious records, but only for Roman Catholics and the Church of Ireland. Each county was divided up by the Church authorities into administrative districts. Which parish you lived in generally dictated where you attended church and, for women, where you married. Other denominations, eg Presbyterians, didn?t use the parish system and which church you attended was often just a matter of personal preference and not necessarily the nearest to where you lived. Many towns and villages had several Presbyterian churches. Presbyterian would be the most common denomination in this area of Ireland, even today, and Belfast has something like 50 Presbyterian churches. So a lot of records to check through. Not all churches have records for the mid 1800s. Some have been lost over the years due to neglect and, in the case of Belfast, due to German bombing in WW2.
Most of the church records that do survive have been copied and are held in PRONI, the public record office in Belfast. They are not on-line and a personal visit is required to access them. But there are probably 300 Church of Ireland and Presbyterian churches in Co Antrim. That?s a formidable number of records to go through, if you have no idea where the families originated.
I have attached a map of the parishes of Co Antrim. There?s 78.
http://www.ancestryireland.com/civil-parish-maps-for-ulster/civil-parishes-of-county-antrim/
There are no Hamptons in Co Antrim in the fragments of the 1851 census that survive. I checked Griffiths Valuation (c 1860) and there was only 1 Hampton household listed in Co Antrim. In Belfast
Rootsireland (a subscription site) had a David Hampton baptism in Co Down in 1845. I don?t have a subscription so can?t tell you the full details. I wouldn?t rush to assume that it?s your family. Though rootsireland have a lot of records on their site, there?s a lot they don?t have, and so you need to bear that in mind when searching. Only if the mother?s name proved to be Orr, or some other data linked it to your family, would I pay any attention to that match.
I searched the PRONI wills site, and though there?s 78 Hamptons listed there?s not a single one in Co Antrim, apart from some in Belfast.
http://applications.proni.gov.uk/DCAL_PRONI_WillsCalendar/WillsSearch.aspx
I still think it?s worth checking out David with the church authorities in New Zealand. You might be surprised at the biographical information they may have.
What about John Hampton?s marriage and death certificates. What parents names do they give?
Elwyn