Back to Message Board

Irish Emigration Mystery - Wilson, Kelly, O'Malley

I have recently been puzzling over the circumstances surrounding my great grandmother's emigration from Ireland to the United States. It is interesting to me that she came to the United States by herself at the age of 21 in June/July 1923, went to stay with a "cousin Mrs. Gordon" in Pennsylvannia, sometime later within the year moved to New Mexico, and then got married in August 1924. She made at least two trips that I know of back to Ireland (then called the Irish Free State) in 1928 and 1936 to visit her family and as far as I know, didn't ever become a US citizen (the US 1930 census record lists her as "alien").

There are a lot of things about her life I'd like to know about, but one of them in particular is how exactly she was related to this "cousin Mrs. Gordon" who she went to stay with when she first came to the United States. I realize it is possible that the "cousin" title that she gave to Mrs. Gordon may not have been accurate, but I thought I'd ask the helpful members of Irelandxo if they know of any resources I could use to verify whether or not there is an actual relation. Here is some more information:

My great grandmother's birth name was Mary Ellen Wilson (born Nov 4, 1901 in Co. Dublin) to John Wilson (Co. Antrim) and Mary Ellen Kelly (Co. Mayo). She went by the name "Helen" especially when she came to the United States (Helen/Helene is on most of her documentation). When she was married, she went by the name Helen Wilson Baca. On the ship manifest that she came over on, she is listed as Mary H. Wilson. The ship, President Monroe, arrived in New York on Jul 3, 1923. The Ellis island immigration records state that she was going to stay with "Cousin Mrs. Gordon at 420 Ferree Street, Coraopolis, Pennsylvannia, United States".

As far as what I could dig up on her "Cousin Mrs. Gordon", I found that at the time she went by Mrs. Helen Gordon. Based on a marriage certificate that I found, she married a Luke Gordon in Mercer, Pennsylvannia on May 5, 1910. On the marriage certificate (see the linked dropbox file for more details), she is listed as "Nellie O'Malley" born in Ireland on October 9, 1878. Her occupation is listed as a housekeeper and the certificate says she was not married before. Her husband, Luke Gordon, is documented as being born on July 20, 1844 in Ireland. His occupation is listed as a hotel owner and the certificate states he was married before, but his wife died on July 24, 1909. Luke Gordon's death certificate (he passed on Jan 2, 1917) shows that both he and his parents were born in Ireland, but doesn't say where or give his parent's names. It also confirms his wife as "Helene O'Malley Gordon". Helen's death certificate shows that she passed away on September 29, 1939 in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvannia. While her death certificate also states that she and her parents were born in Ireland (doesn't give counties), it does give her parent's names. Her mother is listed as Nora Barrett (first name could be short for Honor or Honora) and her father is listed as John O'Malley.

Given the last name O'Malley, I am trying to determine how Mary Ellen Wilson, and Helen O'Malley Gordon, might be related. This is an outline of Mary Ellen Wilson's family tree:

father: John Wilson (born 1872, Co. Antrim), paternal grandfather: David James Wilson (born 1847, Co. Antrim), paternal grandmother: Catherine McGuigan (born 1848, Co. Antrim), John Wilson's siblings: Margaret (born 1869, Co. Antrim), Mary (born 1875, Co. Antrim), William (born 1877, Co. Antrim), Ellen (born 1880, Co. Antrim), Sarah (born 1882, Co. Antrim), David (born 1885, died 1889, Co. Antrim) David (born 1890, Co. Antrim)

mother: Mary Ellen Kelly (born 1874, Co. Mayo), maternal grandfather: William Kelly (1841/1848, Co. Mayo), maternal grandmother: Mary Malley (born 1842/1847 in Co. Mayo), Mary Ellen Kelly's siblings: John (1866/1871, Co. Mayo), Edward (1870, Co. Mayo), Margaret (1876, Co. Mayo), Catherine (Kate) (1878, Co. Mayo), Thomas Kelly (1883, Co. Mayo)

The only similarities that I really see is Helen Gordon's maiden name "O'Malley" being a version of "Malley" which was the maiden name of Mary Ellen Wilson's maternal grandmother. I'm also thinking it's possible that Helen Gordon could be a child of Mary Ellen Wilson's grandfathers or grandmother's sisters, who married someone with the last name O'Malley and had a child who would be Helen O'Malley Gordon. Unfortunately, it's been difficult to research that far back when you're looking at the 1840s.

I realize that determining this connection is somewhat of a long shot, but I thought I'd put my question out there and see what I could find. I posted other potential leads on this mystery relation below:

Dropbox file

  • I found a written family history of Luke Gordon, which states he was born in Co. Mayo to a Darby Gordon (1821-1872, Co. Mayo) and a Jane Feeney (1821-1874). A 1880 US census states he immigrated to the United States in 1864. Luke had previously been married to a Bridget McHugh (~born 1850, Co. Sligo). He married Bridget in 1871 in Rhode Island. Maybe Helen Gordon was from the same area?
  • Helen Gordon's death certificate puts her birth year at 1876 and the 1920 US census puts her as being born in 1882
IrelandXO member

3 replies

Welcome to IrelandXO!

The "cousin" Nellie O'Malley could have been a first or second cousin. A second-cousin connection was equally tight if they grew up in the same area.

So I recommend you delve into the family of Helen O'Malley aka Ellen / Eleanor Malley (b. 1878) dau. of Honora Barrett & John O'Malley in the district of Westport, Co. Mayo... 

>> please link your post to the civil parish of KILMEENA and add Nellie to the ancestor page there

 

Honor aka Nora Barrett & John O'Malley of Moyour (RC parish of KILMEENA as well)  have the following children on record:

Bridget Malley (b. 1873) and Sarah Malley (b. 1876) 

KILMEENA RC Parish was adjacent to AUGHAVAL / OUGHAVAL RC parish (where your Kelly/ Mally ancestors resided). 

 

Parish/District:  AUGHAVAL RC parish / civil parish of OUGHAVAL 

William Kelly & Mary O'Malley of Castlebar St., Westport have no marriage record on RootsIreland (that would have been a help!)

Among their children's baptism records, the godparents were: Richard, Pat, John, Margaret, & Ellen Kelly; Patrick Ryder;  Margaret Bourke; so hold on to these names for more family clues.

 

==========

Parish / District:   NEWTOWNABBEY civil parish of BALLYNURE

David Wilson & Catherine McGuigan both of Mill Lawn, Ballyclare married 24-Dec-1867 @ BALLYCLARE ORTH Presbyterian Church. Both were Mill Workers.

 

Sorry I don't have time to dig deeper on Nellie, but this should give you enough leads to link in with your parishes of origin and discover more!

 

Rua

Hi

John O'Malley & Honor Barrett of Moyaur, Kilmeena listed above had a daughter Ellen O'Malley born on 16th December 1867. She is possibly Helen O'Malley Gordon. Have often seen 10+ differances in age declared!. Her mother Honor VBarrett born 1846 per 1901 census.

Regards

Gerard, Parish Liaison Lackagh

Rua and Gerard,

Thank you both very much for looking in to my mystery! You both were very helpful and I believe I have some more leads now. I even found a few more siblings for Ellen Malley (born in 1867) to John Mally and Honor Barrett (brothers Patrick and John and another sister named Honor). Gerard, you're certainly right about the huge age differences (1878 vs. 1867 here) - I think I'm still getting used to that as I do my research. 

I'll add ancestors to the correct parishes as I learn more. Thanks again for really coming through. People on this site are amazingly helpful.

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.