Back to Message Board

How To Prove Family

I have been searching for my Doyle family in County Cork for some time. The other day I decided to try to find all baptisim records for John Doyle born 11 Jan 1840 in all of Ireland (all records available). I expected to find something in Cork as his death certificate says he was born in Cork. John Doyle was my great-grandfather. Well I found a record for John Doyle born 11 Jan 1840 in Dublin and baptised 13 Jan 1840 in Dublin. His parents were Thomas Doyle and Mary Lyons. I don't have much information on John Doyle going back but I do have information coming forward. He in the USA in 1858 and he married Sarah Fury. Their first child, a daughter, was named Mary, the second child, a son, was named John, the third child, a son, was named Thomas. This naming pattern makes me believe I have found my great-grandfather and his parents but I don't know how to prove it. Does anyone have any ideas for me? The baptism took place in Dublin, St. Nicholas Parish/Church/Congregation. I guess that means Dublin city and the church of St. Nicholas?

I don't believe he was from Cork as the death certificate had all kinds of information on it that I know for a fact is wrong, consequently I believe the county was also wrong and this baptism record may be correct.

I'd appreciate any help or ideas anyone has.

Mary Todd

mtodd81

5 replies

Mary:

Welcome back!

I think you have a good lead but more work is needed.

Do you know if your Thomas had any siblings. There are other baptismal records for children of Thomas Doyle and Mary Lyons in St. Nicholas . There is also a November 22 1843 marriage record for a couple by that name in St. Nicholas church. Maybe there was a second couple with those names or they married late after some children were born.

Any naturalization records available?

Have you had an autosomal DNA test?

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Hi Roger,

It's John Doyle I'm researching.  Thomas is only a possibility of being my John Doyle's father but due to the naming of John's children I think it's a good possibility.

I know absolutely nothing about John Doyle prior to his coming to the USA.  Supposedly he arrived in 1858.  I believe the  birth year of 1840 is valid as that was pretty much consistant in census records, on his death certificate, and on his headstone.  As for Thomas Doyle, I don't know if he ever left Ireland and I don't think John Doyle ever became a citizen, at least I was not able to find any record of naturalization on NARA.

I have had a DNA test (3 of them) but with so little to go on I haven't had much luck.  Also I did believe John Doyle was from Cork and there have been a few matches to people from Cork and some from Dublin.  I would love to find people known to be descended from Thomas Doyle and Mary Lyons and see if we have a DNA match.  That would answer the question of Thomas Doyle being my 2nd great-grandfather.

Mary Todd

 

mtodd81

Hi again, Roger,

I just did a little searching and found the attached Parish Register for 1880 listing John and Mary Doyle.  I think it says they are deceased but not sure.  It has John Doyle listed and Sarah Webster (??).  I can't tell if these are just names or if these people are actually living in Ireland in 1880.  If they are living in Ireland in 1880 then I have been able to prove this is not the right family.  Can you determine what the register says?  It's the 4th one down on the left.

Thank you,

Mary Todd

mtodd81

Mary:

The register is saying that the parents of John Doyle were Thomas Doyle and Mary Lyons and then indicates deceased. Not sure if it means both parents are deceased or just Thomas. I don't see any records where it indicates that one parent is alive and the other deceased. Civil records of marriages only required the name of the father.Not clear whether they lived in Ireland or another country. John would have provided the info.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Hi Roger,

Thank you for your response.  I didn't realize it was a marriage record but his means if John Doyle was in Ireland in 1880 then it is not my John Doyle. At least I can eliminate this family.  Thanks for your help.

Mary Todd

mtodd81

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.