Back to Message Board

How can I find out where my family came from in Ireland?

Hi,

Thank you for letting me join this group. My maiden name is Elizabeth Thorne. I had my DNA test done through Ancestry and found out that I am 47 % Irish. All my life I thought I was just Welsh, English and German (25 %). This was so new to me and I have no idea as to how to start to find out why I am so much Irish. I would love to find out and any information would be greatly appreciated. My Welsh families include surnames: Williams, Morgan, Morse, Davis/Davies, Thomas, Phelps, Needs and more. My English surnames are Thorne, Davison/Davidson, Scott, Newick, Western and more.

Thank you again,

Elizabeth Thorne (Bynon)

Jessieinpa3@aol.com

8 replies

Beth,

I’d take most DNA ethnicity analysis with a pinch of salt. Mostly harmless entertainment, and about as accurate as a horoscope.

According to the London Times on 16th June 2019, Professor Mark Thomas from University College London said: “Ethnicity is a socially constructed category, not a genetic one. Genetic tests cannot assign an ethnicity unless people start to construct ethnicities on the basis of genetic tests. They can identify genetic clusters in modern populations and compare your genes to the different clusters but there’s very little ancestry inference in that. It doesn’t mean it’s where your genes come from.”

DNA testing seems to assume that people never moved which is just nonsense. There has been so much internal migration around the British Isles in the past 4000 years as to make a DNA breakdown between Irish, Welsh, Scots, English etc pretty meaningless. Most of the population all share a common Brythonic origin ie they are descended from people who migrated north through France as the last ice age retreated. When they got to Britain they swarmed around everywhere. Some moved north to Scotland, some west to Wales. And many continued to move after that for military, economic and cultural reasons. Though southern England has been inhabited for 400,000 years, Ireland has only been inhabited for about 8000 years. Many of its early settlers came from Britain. Then many Irish moved to Scotland, notably around 495AD when the kingdom of Dalriada was established by the Scotiae tribe from Co. Antrim, who gave Scotland it’s name, and who ruled Scotland and part of Ulster. So Scotland is named after an invading Irish tribe who came in sufficiently large numbers to be able to rename the country and to introduce their own language, ie gaelic. In the 1600s, 100,000 Scots and a similar number of English and Welsh moved to Ireland as a part of the Plantation of Ireland and also because of a severe famine in Scotland in the late 1600s. From the 1800s they were moving back from Ireland to Britain in hundreds of thousands because the employment prospects were better there. Therefore the idea of the Irish and the Welsh, Scots & English being distinct ethnic groups for DNA purposes is just daft.

So most of the population of Ireland shares common DNA with people in Britain (and perhaps Germany). Trying to draw a distinction between them is therefore is dodgy science. The genes and DNA of the peoples of Ireland, Wales and Scotland are so closely related no scientific test can really determine separate ethnicity. (DNA is good for lots of other aspects of ancestry though).

You should just try tracing your family back accurately generation by generation, using birth, death & marriage records, censuses, wills and the other sources open to genealogists. That’s the only reliable way of determining your origins.

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Hello Elwyn,

Thank you for your response. I have been researching for 28 years and haven't gone back as far as Ireland. My dad always told me his grandmother was born in Ireland but I found out she was actually born in England.

I will keep researching in hopes of finding what I want.

Sincerely,

Beth

Jessieinpa3@aol.com

Try www.johngrenham.com ;

That paternal grandmother that was born in England may well have belonged to an Irish family. When times were tight in Ireland, it was common for the Irish to go find a paying job in England, and send what money they could back to Ireland. 

One of my great-great-grandfathers settled in England after serving in the English army and joined the Anglican church, but we recently found out that he was born Roman Catholic in Dublin. 

Happy hunting!

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

bob.moore.guel…

Take a look at Irish Genealogy Toolkit.   https://www.irish-genealogy-toolkit.com ; Among much other helpful information and guidance it has a section on emigration to Britain. 

As Elwyn said, there has been much mixing of populations of Ireland and Britain for a long time. Knowing some background history may help you understand. Ireland was ruled by English monarchs for over 700 years. 

Following up Bob's point about his army ancestor : Around a third of the British Army consisted of Irishmen in 19th century.  Thousands of soldiers were stationed in Ireland at any one time during 19thC. 10's of thousands at peak deployment. There were barracks all over the place. Some of those soldiers married local women. ( A soldier with an English surname who belonged to a Welsh regiment married into one of my Irish families while stationed in Ireland.)

Searching the Archives  catalogue of my English county for any mention of my Irish surnames, I found vagrant passes allowing people to travel through the county en-route to Liverpool to board ship back to Ireland. These dated 1790s-1830s. Many were for discharged soldiers.  (Britain was at war with France 1793-1815.) Some were civilians. As Bob said, it was common practice for Irish people to go to Britain for paid work, because there were few opportunities at home.

It's estimated that a quarter of the population of my home county in England have Irish ancestry. Much of this is due to immigration in 2nd half of 19thC.

You mention Welsh ancestry. Wales has links with some counties in Leinster and Munster. On my first visit to Cork City I initially thought it was full of Welsh people on holiday but discovered they were all local. I believe I'm not the only person to be confused. 

questor37@gmail.com

Hi, this is how you find out......
your mothers maiden name and where she was born.
Then we find her family.
Keep going back in census records until we find the mention of Ireland.
then we search the Ireland sites.
One guy I helped, took me 2.5 hours, he had been searching for 57 years.
You just have to work backwards.
Margot

 

 

Margot Secrette

 

Hi, im trying to find out the location of my ancestor Micheal Collins born 1839/40.I dont have a location and have looked on ancestry. I have mixed reports from family who say Armagh but think this may have been his wife Margaret Savage. He met Margaret in Glasgow but have no marriage cir. One side states Conakilty and Knock, But i think as many of the Collins name came from Cork and the infamous Micheal Collins came from there it difficult to find location. If you coul dgive me some idea on where to explore further i would be grateful. Mandy

 

IrelandXO member

Hello, Mandy.  You seem to have strayed into someone else's thread, begun by Beth. It would be better if you start a new thread for yourself. Just call it Michael Collins born 1839/40.  Repeat in your first post what you wrote here (except for the bit about Michael Collins). Then someone can answer with some advice.

Btw I take it you meant to say "the famous Michael Collins" rather than "infamous". You don't need to mention him in your new thread. 

questor37@gmail.com

 

Hi Downey from Scull,
you say............................
Hi, im trying to find out the location of my ancestor Micheal Collins born 1839/40.I dont have a location and have looked on ancestry. I have mixed reports from family who say Armagh but think this may have been his wife Margaret Savage. He met Margaret in Glasgow but have no marriage cir.
So.......
Depending on where you live, Scotland or any other part of the UK, the records in Scotlands People should be where to find your info.
On the Births of children it states where the parents married. I know this as this is how I found my husbands people. Then I located the marriage cert and got their place of bith.
Their son who became my husbands grandfather spoke with a very broad Irish accent. At the time of his fathers death he was living in Dublin, South King Street. (eventually moved to the UK)
I searched for him, this was before we had all these records on line, then I joined one site and got him, he was born in Scotland! his Mother was from Templemore in County Derry and his father was from Colchester in Essex, England. Then I traced his sister and brother also go info on the 2 children who had passed on.
Scotlands People, I booked a day in the Edinburgh office some years ago £20.00 for the day and had a pc from 10.00 to 16.00, great every record you could think of.
Scotlands People can be expensive if you do it on line. 
Conakilty..........Clonakilty is in County Cork. I see a tree with Conakilty in Ancestry is that yours?
Try here......
https://registers.nli.ie

this is Clonakilty
https://registers.nli.ie/parishes/0033

Margot

 

 

 

Margot Secrette

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.