Thanks for those wonderful attachments - feel free to add them too on our XO Chronicles Project.
Isn't it sad that a man so respected in his community died at quite a young age.
I had a look and located 4 baptisms for children born to Peter and Catherine:
Henry - 5th Dec 1836 Parish of Armagh, Co. Armagh
James - 18th Jul 1839 Parish of Clonfeacle, Co. Tyrone
Sara - 1st Oct 1841 Parish of Clonfeacle, Co. Tyrone
Peter - 8th March 1844, Parish of Clonfeacle, Co. Tyrone.
As you can see from the above RC Parish maps, the Roman Catholic Parish of Clonfeacle is divided in two parts. The parishes are neighbours so the family may have moved a short distance after the birth of Henry and so later children were baptised in Co. Tyrone. I couldn't locate a marriage record for Peter and Catherine, they may have married in her home Parish (as was tradition) at a time that predates parish records.
I am not 100% convinced though that these are the correct records, especially given your cousin's information that shows Henry recorded under different parents. In the same way, we can neither prove nor disprove our current information.
One thing you could do is take out a short subscription to rootsireland.ie and check out all of the baptisms for a child named Arthur (not a very common first name) and write out a list of who each set of parents are. Taking each set of parents search for ANY children born to them and if an Arthur and a Henry are listed it is more likely that they are the correct parents for your Henry. There is certainly reason to call into question the above though I don't rule it out either.
Do you know if Henry left a will, as this might shed further light on things.
Let me know what you think
Clare
Genealogy Support