Whooo... that's exciting news Chris ... keep me posted!
Here comes the roller-coaster ride...
Knockerra Village had its own RC Chapel in the 1830s aka St. Senan's (RC Parish of Knockerra & Killimer).
And this seems to be the general area that Timothy Nolans turn up...
(It will help to get your spreadsheet "map-oriented"... look north-east of Kilrush town, from Ballykett to Knockerra Lough).
1821 Timothy Nolan freehold at Kilrush ... 1826 Timothy Nolan freehold at Moyada Begg (not here on 1855 land records, but note Brew is) ... 1868 Timothy Nolan (b.1816) died in Kilrush ...
1901 & 1911 Timothy aka Thady Nolan (1853-1933) farmer, m. 1896, son of Denis Nolan, res. at Knockerry West (aka Knockerra).
______________________________________________________________________________
*POSSIBLE LEAD* Honoria (b.1855) dau. of Anthony Nolan @13b Knockerra, labourer, married Thomas Tubridy in 1877. This couple are not turning up in the Irish Census Records (presumed emigrated) do you have any Tubridy neighbours on your UK Census returns? How about , Browne, Mulqueen, Moloney?
___________________________________________________________________________
Take note: at a time when most could not, these Nolan tenant farmers could afford headstones...
KNOCKERRA Nolan graveyard transcriptions (beginning 1812)
Also, I have discovered that the Nolans of Kilrush were originally very well-off landholding middlemen / merchants rubbing shoulders with local gentry. They held leases to large tracts of land all over these parts, had shops in Kilrush and had branched into Carrigaholt by 1810 and into Nenagh by the 1840s.
Given names handed down were Anthony, Denis, George, Richard.
Anthony Nolan, of Lack East who christened a son 'George' in 1865, was a Gentleman Farmer. George Nolan of Frances Street, Kilrush who christened a son 'Anthony' in 1865, was a Civil Engineer.
See George Nolan (1749-1810) of Carrigaholt interred at Kilrush Church of Ireland graveyard (his eldest daughter 1775-1818 married George Brew). George was either father/brother to Anthony Nolan of Durha, who was a £50 freeholder in Carrigaholt in 1821; c.f. Anthony Nolan of Ballykett (Kilrush) who married Mary Brew (1754-1822) and is interred on Scattery Island.
The Brews were under-agents to Col. Vandeleur. In 1841 Anthony Nolan contributed £10 towards a Reward for discovering the murderers of Thomas Foley Brew of Shyan KILMIHIL; son of Kilrush Postmaster, William Brew Esq. (1784-1846)
I have no doubt the Kilrush Nolans are all related in some way...
Let's hope your DNA results hold the key!