Dear Jane and Maggie
apologies for the delay but your excellent questions urged me to double check everything which was extremely helpful but took a little time! I am in Dublin next Monday and Tuesday, would you suggest a visit to either the The National Archives of Ireland or The Irish Family History Centre, possibly booking a help session from a Geneaologist?
I think the next step could be to find Ellen Kelly with her possible siblings together in Ireland, possibly baptised with the same parents? To find a marriage to Anthony Carr would be great but that might be difficult - see note below.
Jane
I will certainly look at creating an Ancestor profile for both Anthony Carr and Ellen Kelly.
I have looked at other names associated with them and found the following.
1. 1835 Catholic Baptism of James Carr in St Chads Catholic Church Birmingham. Godparents Bridget Lee and Michael Nolan. In the 1841 Birmingham census there is a Bridget Lee born Ireland married to a William Lee and in the same household 5 members of a Kelley family. All born in Ireland. Furthermore there is a marriage of a William Lee to a Bridget Kelly in a Birmingham CofE Church in 1836. It is possible that Bridget and the other members of the Kelly family are from the same family.
2. 1843 Birmingham St Chads Catholic Church baptism records Ellen (Ellena) Carr with parents Ellen (Ellena) Carr and Anthony (Antonii) Carr include two witnesses, Thomas Kelly and Bridget (Brigitta) Kilmartin. Is it possible that Thomas Kelly is also a sibling of Ellen?
Maggie
I believe they are the same couple as most of the children also appear with them in the 1841 and widowed Anthony in 1851 census.
The Birmingham St Chads Catholic Church (now Cathedral) Archives transcript of the baptism register for my direct ancestor James Carr b 1833 reads as follows.
Name: James Carr
Born: 11/12/1835
Baptised: 27/12/1835
Parents: Anthony Carr and Ellen Carr (Maiden Name Kelly).
God parents Timothy Rogers and Bridget Lee
Unfortunately there is no reference to a place of residence.
Also shown in the 1841 census is son Thomas. I have the birth cert of Thomas confirming mothers maiden name as Kelly.
Also in 1843 the birth certificate of daughter Ellen gives Anthony and Ellen as parents. This certificate also mentions mother Ellens previous married name of Kearman, formerly Kelly.
I think you are right about the reason for marrying in a C of E Church, however I have not yet been able to find an earlier Catholic marriage between Anthony and Ellen in England or Ireland even though they had James in 1835. Is it is possible that as both were widowed, they only ever married in the know 1843 CofE Marriage in Birmingham?
At this stage I can’t think of any way to find out more about Anthony other than possibly trying to go through his wife Ellen Kelly?
=========
Thanks again for your help, I appreciate this might be too complicated to expect a further reply although of course any such help would be appreciated. Your views on the best place to visit in Dublin would be helpful.
best regards
Dave Carr