Back to Message Board

Help with Carr and Kelley, early 1800's

My ancestors migrated to Birmingham England sometime in the 1820s and although I have the relevant UK records so far I have been unable to trace them back in Ireland.

I fully appreciate I may need to visit the National Library of Ireland but in the meantime any advice welcome.

Anthony Carr was born in about 1806 in Ireland. His fathers name was James who was a Butler. Note that in Ancestry Carr was transcribed as Carr in 1841 and Cann in 1851 but I think this was an error.

He was married to Ellen Kelley or Kelly who was born in about 1802 in Ireland. Her fathers name was John Kelley, a labourer.

Their 1843 CofE Birmingham marriage certificate indicates that both were widowed when they married. Ellens maiden name is shown as late Kearman formerly Kelly Note the Godfather is a Thomas Kelly - possibly a brother? I have not been able to find any reference to earlier marriages.

I believe that they may have been married prior to this in a Catholic Church as their children born in the 1830s were all baptised at St Chads RC Church in Birmingham. I believe that a second marriage in a CoE Church was often done at that time.

Many thanks

davec

6 replies

Dear Davec:

Many thanks for your post to the Ireland Reaching Out message board and welcome to the site.

It is often very difficult to research back before the early 1800s due to the lack of records and this may be the case with your family research.  You should note all names associated with this family's life events including births/baptisms, marriages as often other family members were sponsors and/or witnesses.  These other family members might yield further clues to your research and even an Ireland location.  

You might consider creating an Ancestor Profile for Anthony Carr and for Ellen Kelly.  The profiles can be created through the XO Chronicles link at the top of the page.  

You mention in your post that Anthony Carr's father was named James and he was a Butler.  Do you mean that that was his occupation?  If that is the case, it may be possible to find further information about him if he was employed on an estate.  You might consider that aspect of research.  

If you need any further assistance, please let us know.

Kind regards,

Jane

 

jhalloranryan@…

Were  Anthony and Ellen both Catholics? Are you certain that the 1843  Birmingham marriage  was the same couple who had children baptised at St. Chad's? What information about parents was in baptism register?  Weddings in England pre 1837 had to be in C. of E. to be legal. They may have married in a Catholic church in Ireland and later worried that it wasn't valid in England.

questor37@gmail.com

Dear Jane and Maggie

apologies for the delay but your excellent questions urged me to double check everything which was extremely helpful but took a little time! I am in Dublin next Monday and Tuesday, would you suggest a visit to either the The National Archives of Ireland or The Irish Family History Centre, possibly booking a help session from a Geneaologist? 

I think the next step could be to find Ellen Kelly with her possible siblings together in Ireland, possibly baptised with the same parents? To find a marriage to Anthony Carr would be great but that might be difficult - see note below.

Jane

I will certainly look at creating an Ancestor profile for both Anthony Carr and Ellen Kelly.

I have looked at other names associated with them and found the following.

1. 1835 Catholic Baptism of James Carr in St Chads Catholic Church Birmingham. Godparents Bridget Lee and Michael Nolan. In the 1841 Birmingham census there is a Bridget Lee born Ireland married to a William Lee and in the same household 5 members of a Kelley family. All born in Ireland. Furthermore there is a marriage of a William Lee to a Bridget Kelly in a Birmingham CofE Church in 1836. It is possible that Bridget and the other members of the Kelly family are from the same family.

2. 1843 Birmingham St Chads Catholic Church baptism records Ellen (Ellena) Carr with parents Ellen (Ellena) Carr and Anthony (Antonii) Carr include  two witnesses, Thomas Kelly and Bridget (Brigitta) Kilmartin. Is it possible that Thomas Kelly is also a sibling of Ellen?

 

Maggie

I believe they are the same couple as most of the children also appear with them in the 1841 and widowed Anthony in 1851 census.

The Birmingham St Chads Catholic Church (now Cathedral) Archives transcript of the baptism register for my direct ancestor James Carr b 1833 reads  as follows.

Name: James Carr

Born: 11/12/1835

Baptised: 27/12/1835

Parents: Anthony Carr and Ellen Carr (Maiden Name Kelly).

God parents Timothy Rogers and Bridget Lee

Unfortunately there is no reference to a place of residence.

Also shown in the 1841 census is son Thomas. I have the birth cert of Thomas confirming mothers maiden name as Kelly.

Also in 1843 the birth certificate of daughter Ellen gives Anthony and Ellen as parents. This certificate also mentions mother Ellens previous married name of Kearman, formerly Kelly.

I think you are right about the reason for marrying in a C of E Church, however I have not yet been able to find an earlier Catholic marriage between Anthony and Ellen in England or Ireland even though they had James in 1835. Is it is possible that as both were widowed, they only ever married in the know 1843 CofE Marriage in Birmingham?

At this stage I can’t think of any way to find out more about Anthony other than possibly trying to go through his wife Ellen Kelly?

=========

Thanks again for your help, I appreciate this might be too complicated to expect a further reply although of course any such help would be appreciated. Your views on the best place to visit in Dublin would be helpful. 

best regards

Dave Carr

 

 

 

 

IrelandXO member

Dear Jane and Maggie

apologies for the delay but your excellent questions urged me to double check everything which was extremely helpful but took a little time! I am in Dublin next Monday and Tuesday, would you suggest a visit to either the The National Archives of Ireland or The Irish Family History Centre, possibly booking a help session from a Geneaologist? 

I think the next step could be to find Ellen Kelly with her possible siblings together in Ireland, possibly baptised with the same parents? To find a marriage to Anthony Carr would be great but that might be difficult - see note below.

Jane

I will certainly look at creating an Ancestor profile for both Anthony Carr and Ellen Kelly.

I have looked at other names associated with them and found the following.

1. 1835 Catholic Baptism of James Carr in St Chads Catholic Church Birmingham. Godparents Bridget Lee and Michael Nolan. In the 1841 Birmingham census there is a Bridget Lee born Ireland married to a William Lee and in the same household 5 members of a Kelley family. All born in Ireland. Furthermore there is a marriage of a William Lee to a Bridget Kelly in a Birmingham CofE Church in 1836. It is possible that Bridget and the other members of the Kelly family are from the same family.

2. 1843 Birmingham St Chads Catholic Church baptism records Ellen (Ellena) Carr with parents Ellen (Ellena) Carr and Anthony (Antonii) Carr include  two witnesses, Thomas Kelly and Bridget (Brigitta) Kilmartin. Is it possible that Thomas Kelly is also a sibling of Ellen?

 

Maggie

I believe they are the same couple as most of the children also appear with them in the 1841 and widowed Anthony in 1851 census.

The Birmingham St Chads Catholic Church (now Cathedral) Archives transcript of the baptism register for my direct ancestor James Carr b 1833 reads  as follows.

Name: James Carr

Born: 11/12/1835

Baptised: 27/12/1835

Parents: Anthony Carr and Ellen Carr (Maiden Name Kelly).

God parents Timothy Rogers and Bridget Lee

Unfortunately there is no reference to a place of residence.

Also shown in the 1841 census is son Thomas. I have the birth cert of Thomas confirming mothers maiden name as Kelly.

Also in 1843 the birth certificate of daughter Ellen gives Anthony and Ellen as parents. This certificate also mentions mother Ellens previous married name of Kearman, formerly Kelly.

I think you are right about the reason for marrying in a C of E Church, however I have not yet been able to find an earlier Catholic marriage between Anthony and Ellen in England or Ireland even though they had James in 1835. Is it is possible that as both were widowed, they only ever married in the know 1843 CofE Marriage in Birmingham?

At this stage I can’t think of any way to find out more about Anthony other than possibly trying to go through his wife Ellen Kelly?

=========

Thanks again for your help, I appreciate this might be too complicated to expect a further reply although of course any such help would be appreciated. Your views on the best place to visit in Dublin would be helpful. 

best regards

Dave Carr

 

 

 

 

IrelandXO member

Hello, Dave. I've just seen a notification about a reply. I missed your previous replies. Have you been to Dublin? 

Civil law and religious guidelines on marriage differed in Ireland and England and was complicated in 19th century. That's why I asked if Anthony and Ellen were both Catholic. As I understand, a Catholic marrying another Catholic in Ireland usually married in a Catholic church. A Catholic who married a spouse who wasn't Catholic was supposed to marry in a Church of Ireland if they wanted the marriage to be legally recognised e.g. for inheritance. That would have been the situation until civil registration for Catholic marriages began in Ireland in 1864. Marriages in England had to be in Church of England (except for Quakers and Jews) until civil registration of marriages began in England in.1837. Some Catholic couples in England had a religious ceremony in a Catholic church, often the previous day or the same day, as well as the required C. of E. wedding.  Some Catholic couples continued to marry in C. of E. even after 1837. It was cheaper and simpler. Such marriages were recognised as valid by R.C. authorities until a change to Catholic canon law on marriage in 1908. 

Re. the baptism of James Carr at St. Chad's in 1835 with godparents Bridget Lee & Michael Nolan. Was that a different child to James Carr, son of Anthony & Ellen who was baptised December 1835? Kelly and Nolan are such common Irish  names. 

The Thomas Kelly who was godfather to Ellen in 1843 may have been a brother of her mother, but may have been a cousin or another relative, or just a friend, neighbour or workmate. It might have depended on who was around. Sometimes there were stand-in godparents if a chosen godparent couldn't be present at the baptism. Register usually stated "A.B. stood for C.D." in such cases. Was Thomas Kelly also a wedding witness? What about other sponsors, Bridget Kilmartin and Timothy Rogers - any idea who they were?

   Might the surname of Ellen's first husband have been Kiernan or Keenan? Were there any children from either of the previous marriages ?

 

 

questor37@gmail.com

Hi Maggie, Thanks for your reply and sorry you had to wade through so many repeat posts - not sure how that happened! 

We will arrive in Dublin next Monday pm and I hope to use some time on Tuesday to do some research although not quite sure where at this stage - the reviews of the Irish Family History Centre are a bit mixed - any suggestions?

The two James Carr baptisms you mention are the same child.

I am searching through Associated Persons to try and find a cross reference 

For example Bridget Lee is a godparent of James Carr b 1835.

In the 1841 census there is a William and Bridget Lee and in the same household five members of the Kelley family. Kelly or Kelley is the maiden name of Anthonys wife Ellen (James mother). 

I did wonder Bridget may have originally been a Kelley as there is a Birmingham CofE marriage of William Lee and Bridget Kelly on 29/8/1836. 

The problem with this connection is that James was baptised on 27/12/1835 so Bridget would still have had her maiden name Kelly -  unless perhaps she had already married William in a Catholic Church??

This may be clutching at straws so will keep looking.   thanks agaian.  Dave

davec

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.