Sheri,
Rev Park took over as Presbyterian Minister of Ballymoney 1st Presbyterian church around 1817. He decided to conduct a census of the whole parish (so all denominations, not just his own flock) to take stock of the area. The original is with the church records but you can find his data on various websites, including Bill McAfee’s:
http://billmacafee.com
From the early 1600s onwards, Ireland was settled by many Scots (who were mostly Presbyterian, though there were some RC and some Anglican Scots settlers). Many English and some Welsh also settled in Ireland. The intention was to subdue Ireland to prevent it from being used as a launching point for an invasion of Britain by the Spanish or French. (The Spanish Armada had only just been defeated so the threat was seen as very real). The settlement of Ireland was initiated by King James I who was Scottish. Elizabeth I had died with no heirs and so the English invited the Scottish King, King James VI of Scotland to take over the English throne too, so he became King James I of Great Britain & Ireland. As a Scot he trusted his fellow countrymen and encouraged large numbers to settle in Ireland. Most Scots were Presbyterian and to this day Presbyterians are the most common denomination in County Antrim. So that gives you an idea of the numbers that came. 100,000 Scots – 10% of the entire Scottish population – moved to Ireland in the 1600s.
But life in Ireland wasn’t ideal for the Scots or the native Irish. It was very hard to obtain ownership of land (the big landlords mostly wouldn’t sell) and if you were a farmer and improved your farm, you could find your rent hiked up because the value had increased, as a result of your own hard work. There were restrictions on holding public office if you were not Church of Ireland (ie Anglican). The linen industry was stagnated because the American War of Independence had cut off supplies of cotton to Ireland. Linen had replaced cotton but even so business was down. This affected a huge section of the population, especially in the Ulster counties such as Antrim. A series of bad harvests had also affected farmer’s incomes. Taxes to pay for road building and other public works also caused grievances. The natives were restless.
There were risings and agrarian outrages in Co. Antrim in the late 1700s caused by the oppressive and unjust actions of several absentee landlords, Chief amongst whom was Lord Donegall, the proprietor of vast estates, which included most of the land lying between Larne River and the Lagan. When the tenants' leases ran out the landlords, or their agents, advertised the farms, which had been improved and built upon by the tenants, to be let, or sold them over the heads of the tenants. In some cases the rents were raised, in others a heavy fee was demanded for the renewal of the leases, which the poor farmers were unable to pay.
Many of these farms were taken over by rich merchants from Belfast and elsewhere who often put them down in grazing. Others were taken up by Roman Catholics who were only too glad to pay the increased rents or inflated prices to get back upon the land. Thus many of the small farmers and labourers were left homeless.
Catholics had been treated even more harshly than Presbyterians with a range of legal restrictions on matters such as practising their religion, owning a horse worth more than £5, not being allowed to own land outright or hold leases for more than 31 years and so on. The intention was to persuade them to become Anglican, and more subservient to the British Government. Just how fully these penal laws were enforced is subject of much debate because there are many examples of the law not being applied much at all. Most notably in north east Antrim where the biggest landowner was the Earl of Antrim who owned a quarter of the whole county. All through the penal law period, and until the mid 1700s, he was Roman Catholic, and he had thousands of RC tenants, to whom he gave 3 lives leases. So clearly the laws were not always applied very rigorously. All the same there’s no doubt that all through the mid 1600s & 1700s, many Presbyterians and Roman Catholics were aggrieved at the way they were treated by the state. Most Presbyterians would have been broadly loyal to the Crown though, even though they were unhappy with how they had been treated.
In the late 1700s there was a campaign against some of the unfair laws, for fairer voting rights (only the wealthy had votes). These common grievances brought Presbyterians and Roman Catholics together and they formed the United Irishmen whose aims were originally a more just society but which quickly grew into a more revolutionary frame of mind. (They were heavily influenced by the French Revolution in 1793 where the peasants successfully overthrew the aristocracy).
The outcome was that in June 1798 there were various risings across Ireland against the Crown. However support was patchy and the United Irishmen were badly organized and badly led. They were also heavily infiltrated by spies who had advised the Government of most of their plans, and so after some short term initial successes in seizing town like Ballymena, the United Irishmen were quickly routed, and vanquished.
The British Army killed quite a few in the battlefield, and seized most of the main leaders. However the rank and file were allowed to flee and if they got off the battlefield no further action was generally taken against them. Half a dozen leaders were executed to make a point. The middle ranking officers were seen as a potential long term threat (they might regroup and cause more trouble). On the other hand it was recognised that executing hundreds of them would cause further civil disorder. So the cunning solution was to advise them that by trying to overthrow the state they faced a charge of treason - the penalty for which was execution - but that if they undertook to leave the country for good within a specified period of time, accompanied by their wives and children, no further action would be taken. Most quickly accepted that offer and left. And nothing further was ever heard of the United Irishmen. So you could say the Government dealt with them fairly adeptly.
So to summarise, if your ancestor was involved in the United Irishmen, and was executed, it sounds as though he must have been one of the leaders, because not that many were executed (as opposed to those killed in the heat of battle).
It’s probably worth explaining that given that the United Irishmen’s aim was to overthrow the government, they were seen as the Al Qaeda of their day. And they were treated accordingly. Little mercy if they were in the act of attacking. Just as a terrorist would be shot today if caught in the act.
In Ballymoney, the army burned the homes of those known to have been supporters of the United Irishmen. (So half the town). But because the houses were all thatched and adjacent to each other, the fire leapt from building to building and nearly the whole town burned down. Ballymoney 1st Presbyterian church was burned, and some of the pre 1798 baptism records kept there still have burn marks on them.
The local population fled to the countryside and hid in farms and barns. However the army soon left, and then the people returned and rebuilt their houses. Life went on again. Papers I have seen in PRONI in Belfast, between the army commanders, Pitt the Younger (Prime Minister) and Lord Castlereagh (Secretary of Sate for Ireland) recognised that the United Irishmen had been heavily defeated and posed little long term danger. So the politicians tactics were to leave the vast majority alone, thereafter, as no useful purpose would be served by pursuing them. Their focus was on executing a few leaders, and encouraging the middle ranking officers to leave the country. After that the matter was closed. So, in my opinion, McKinlay’s wife and children would have had nothing to fear from the army or the courts. They would have been left alone.
You asked whether a Presbyterian would become RC, as a result of what happened. No. They wouldn’t. They would have remained Presbyterian. Why would you change your denomination? (And most Presbyterians didn’t have much time for Catholicism as a denomination. It’s administrative structure and doctrines mirrored the Church of England, which Presbyterians had broken away from in the 1500s).
You ask what a widow with a load of children would do in 1798? She’d probably go and stay with relatives, and then find another man to marry, quickly.
You ask where the nearest towns were. The answer is Coleraine about 10 miles to the north and Ballymena 20 miles to the south, though Ballymena was badly burned, as it participated in the uprising too. But remember that Ireland at that time was a rural agricultural community. Most people lived in the countryside, and the towns were quite small places where rural folk went from time to time to market or to conduct certain business. Far more people lived in the countryside than in the towns. So Mrs McKinlay might easily have been able to find somewhere to stay in the countryside, rather than in a town, necessarily. I suspect that in the short term she went to relatives, or with folk she knew from church.
I’ll contact someone I know who has researched the United Irishmen in the Ballymoney area, to see if he knows anything of Francis McKinlay and his family.
I have attached some reminiscences written in the 1860s, by someone who was a small child at the time of the 1798 rebellion. It describes events in Broughshane and Ballymena. I don’t suppose things in Ballymoney were terribly different. The description of the dead mens hair blowing in the wind haunts me yet.