Back to Message Board

Francis Foran O'Brien

Hello. My grandfather, Francis O'Brien, was born on July 16, 1896 in Quilty, Clare. His mother was Ellen Foran and he was baptized with her name only and no father listed on the birth certificate. Ellen Foran married Cornelius O'Brien 4 years later in October of 1900. They had three more children, Mary, who apparently died as a baby or child, Patrick and John. Cornelius O'Brien drowned on October 17, 1906 and Francis came to the United States in July of 1908. Ellen, Patrick and John O'Brien came to the United States in 1921.

Ellen Foran's parents were James Foran and Honor Shanahan.

We are trying to determine whether or not Cornelius was my grandfather, Francis', father. If not, does anyone know of a way to find out who it might be? I know this was over 100 years ago, so the only way would probably be some sort of DNA testing, but I don't know if this type of testing exists.

Also, my grandfather is not listed on the 1901 census. Can anyone explain why this would be?

Any further information on the Foran or O'Brien families would be appreciated. Thank you.

IrelandXO member

4 replies

Fáilte!

 

 The 5 year gap between your grandfather's birth and Ellen's marriage to O'Brien does not follow the mores of the time (a shotgun marriage would have taken place very close to the birth). There is no way that the parish priest (or her father) would have allowed such a waiting period, if Corneilus was the father. Corneilus was from Tromra (the adjoining townland to the south). Quilty is a tiny village, and secrets would have been hard kept.

I found Ellen and Corneilus in the 1901 Census, residing in Quilty West with Ellen's widowed mother, Honor Foran and her brothers (fishermen). Your grandfather, Francis, would have been about 5 years old at this point, and Ellen & Corneilus would have been newlyweds (unable to afford a place of their own). It looks like finances were tough for this household, which could explain the absence of your grandfather from the list.

Possible reasons for his name not appearing on the Census (a) he was away visiting or  (b) due to poverty / illigitimacy he was being cared for elswhere (in which case you are searching for an "F.F" age 5 or 6 in a workhouse/ sanatorium/ convent); (c)  he was not recorded on purpose.

If you can get sight of the actual baptismal register, you might be lucky. Sometimes the priests wrote notes in the margins about their suspicions. But its a long shot. Whatever, the case, the apple won't have fallen far from the tree. Your DNA pool will most certainly be in the Quilty vicinity on both sides. 

Hope this helps!

 

 

Rua

Thank you for your response.  My brother was in Ireland many years ago and got a copy of our grandfather's baptism certificate and our great-grandparents' marriage certificate (that's how we found out he was born so long before his parents' marriage and baptized under his mother's name).  My grandfather did not die until my father was 23 years old, but he never told my father about any of this.  I guess it's something no one talked about back then.  My father and I will be traveling to Ireland from the U.S. in June of 2018.  Do you know if it is possible to go to the church and see the actual baptismal register?  Can people do that?  Thank you!

IrelandXO member

It's very possible your grandfather never knew the circumstances of his birth. I have a similar story in my family tree. (The wedding anniversary was never celebrated, so nobody in the family suspected anything. The secret was taken to the grave).

 

You're visiting in June? How wonderful ... Clare is beautiful in the summer!

You may also be able to catch some of the excitement surrounding the The Willie Clancy Music Festival nearby at Miltown Malbay (7 to 15 July, 2018). It'll be hard to find accommodation in the area that week, so book well in advance!

Be sure to check out Tromra Tower (aka Tromra Castle) which would have been a significant local landmark for your family. There are also plenty of beautiful beaches around Quilty. Also the Folk park at Bunratty Castle is highly recommended.

Your heat map would suggest the townland of Rinneen, may have been a Foran point of origin.

You could run a search of historical newspapers for any mention of Quilty or Tromra House to get a sense of the local news in their time. You never know, you may see an O'Brien or Foran mentioned. Especially if O'Brien died young by drowning (fisherman's accident). The IrishNewsArchive is generally good for obituaries of that time.

As for getting a look at the original parish register (DIOCESE OF KILLALOE). Your best bet would be to contact Clare Library who have a wealth of information and can surely answer that question. Seems like they have a lot about the O'Brien's online.

Best of luck!

Rua

Thank you for all the information and suggestions for our visit next year!

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.