Back to Message Board

FITZSIMMONS and ARNOLD parents of Eleanor Alice FITZSIMMONS?

Seeking county of birth for Eleanor Alice FITZSIMMONS born on or around 20 March 1834 in Ireland.

  • Immigrated to USA before 1855, the year she married James A. CARDWELL on 31 January in Union County, Kentucky. She MAY have been a passenger aboard the ship Conqueror, arriving in New York from Liverpool on 24 September 1852. This is not proved.
  • Gave birth to 6 children (actual or estimated birth years in parentheses): Edmund (1856), Warner Taylor (1858), Mary Elizabeth (1861), Annabelle (1863), Catherine (1868), Margaret (1872). To my knowledge, only two of those children had children of their own. I have proven 7 grandchildren. (Note that Eleanor's household included one child born to her husband and his first wife, Sarah Jane Stallions. That child was John Wiley Cardwell, born 1850.)
  • Lived in Kentucky until the early 1900s, when she moved with her daughters to St. Louis, Missouri.
  • Died in St. Louis, Missouri, 14 March 1922. Buried in a large Catholic cemetery in that city. My research has found no Catholic church records for her in Kentucky. I have not researched in St. Louis, but a volunteer genealogist was unsuccessful in locating records in churches there.
  • According to her death certificate, her parents were Ireland-born John ARNOLD and Margaret FITZSIMMONS. I suppose this means they were not married and that Eleanor kept the surname of her mother.
  • I have not found Irish records for her or placed her in a specific county of Ireland. Another researcher suggests that Eleanor and her family may have lived for a time in England, but I have no verification.

Intriguing: The 1850 Federal Census for Union County, Kentucky included four Fitzsimmons men living as laborers in the home of carpenter Isaac Clayton. Those Fitzsimmons men were Thomas, Mike, James, and another Thomas, ranging in age from 18 to 30. I have been unable to connect them to Eleanor, but I would be surprised if there wasn't a connection. Why else would Eleanor settle in tiny, rural Union County, Kentucky?

I welcome any help in connecting Eleanor (a.k.a. Ellen and Alice) to her home county and to any ancestors you can identify. I have a family tree on Ancestry.com (Nelson-Wilkins-Davis-Cardwell Family Tree at http://trees.ancestry.com/tree/967402/family?cfpid=-2023333508). Eleanor was my mother's mother's father's mother.

Thanks.

Fran in Kentucky, USA

Kentucky Fran

4 replies

Fran:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

This Irish Times web site http://www.irishtimes.com/ancestor/surname/   shows you where surnames were found in the mid-19th century. Fitzsimmons was mainly in the Eastern counties of Ireland. However, she could have been a Fitzsimons (like Maureen O'Hara) or Fitzsimon. You can also check Arnold.

I did a search on Roots Ireland from 1829-1839 for an Elexxx Fitzsimmons with a mother Margaret and no records came up. Roots also searches the variant surnames. Possibly the church she was baptized in no longer has records back to that time period, 

Have you considered autosomal DNA testing. Possibly you will match someone who has more info on Eleanor's family in Ireland.

Let me know if you have questions.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Thank you, Roger,  for such a quick response. I have looked at websites with surname distributions, and that information is definitely a clue. I have done autosomal DNA testing via Ancestry.com, and I was pleased when the results showed 33 percent Ireland. Obviously, I have more than one Irish ancestor, but I need to do more with results. I have connected with a few distant cousins, but they don't lead me down my maternal grandmother's line.

I will press on, but I'm loosing faith that I will ever connect Eleanor with a specific county, much less a town or family. The big disadvantage is that the grandson who lived with her for many years and knew her well died young and left three children who were adopted by their mother's second husband. Attempts at tracing them and their descendants have been unsuccessful. The descendants of Eleanor's five grandchildren who stayed in Kentucky have no information on her at all. I seem to be the only one on the planet who is obsessed with finding our Ireland roots!

Best wishes, and thanks again for responding.

Fran

Kentucky Fran

Fran:

One suggestion with your DNA results to expand the matching pool. There is a volunteer run site called Gedmatch www.gedmatch.com  where you can upload your raw Ancestry DNA data and see if you match with someone who tested with Family Tree DNA or 23 and Me (and also uploaded their data to Gedmatch).

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks for the suggestion, Roger. I will do that soon.

Fran

 

Kentucky Fran

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.