Back to Message Board

Ellen Curley - Patrick Cunningham - Looking for help

We are trying so hard to find our family roots in Ireland - We think County Sligo. This is the only family letter we have to go on. Any help would be SO appreciated.

20621 Oahu Circle - Estero, FL 33928

Jan. 21, 1988

First, let me say Ill be happy to help in any way I can. Part of my knowledge is from my own memory because Im 15 years older than your dad. My father, who was born in Cincinnati, loved to hear stories about the Auld Sod and related them to us. Since I dont have exact dates and not always precise places Ill try to get down in story fashion all I know:

On the stony west coast of Ireland in the county of Sligo there lived a family called Curley. In the mid 1850s a girl, Ellen, was born. There were older brothers and sisters. All of Ireland was suffering from the potato famine and most of the sons and daughters in the whole country grew up knowing theyd have to immigrate some day.

Ellen was a beautiful young girl, about 18, when she met Patrick Cunningham, a handsome devil of a rebel. He was a real Irish patriot, straining to either make things better in his country or get out, be successful elsewhere and go back to fulfill his dreams.

I believe he was in his early 20s when he managed to get to America, started to earn money. His first priority was to send for Ellen.

There were other Curleys in Boston at the time either older brothers or cousins of Ellens. There were also Curley relatives in Cincinnati. Also in Cincinnati was Patricks older sister, Mary, who was probably Mrs. Meehan at the time Ellen and Patrick came to Cincinnati to live.

While the wedding may have been in Boston (probably about 1881) the young couple was in Cincinnati at the time Robert was born. There were eight children, five of whom grew to adulthood*:

Born

* Robert Emmet- July 9, 1883

* Charles Stuart -1 years later

* Mary - 1 years later

William - ?

Aileen - ?

* Annette - 1893

* Ralph - 1895

? - ?

Soon after the last baby was born Ellen died, a dreadful tragedy and particularly so for Robert who knew the most about his parents, their dreams and hopes for the future. Being a chip off the old block he thought he could better the family situation and probably Irelands also, so indoctrinated as he was with the patriotism instilled in him he left Cincinnati.

About 14 and with the wealth of a few dollars he ran away (freight train) to Omaha where he had heard there were good jobs. He started as a copy boy for a printing company. He gradually became a printing feeder, heard about better jobs in Chicago and went there to live. It was then about 1901. He sent for his brother, Charlie, to come and live with him and he got Charlie a job in the printing company.

Later Robert had his father, step-mother, and the rest of the family come to Chicago. They set up housekeeping and were all together again for a short period. It was 1905 and Robert married Catherine Agnes Mulcahy on September 27.

Unfortunately soon after that there was a fire in the Patrick Cunningham household. Fortunately no one was injured but the furnishings were destroyed. Patrick was not well. His wife was not either and she was anxious to return to Cincinnati. Robert and Catherine (Kitty) took Pat into live with them. Charlie went to Detroit where he found a good job opportunity. Mary (Aunt Mae to us was about to be married. Robert found foster homes for Annette and Ralph.

Aunt Mae moved to Galesburg, Illinois, and the father spent his time shuttling back and forth with her and her husband and with Rob and Kitty.

Meanwhile Rob and Kitty had started their family:

Born

Mary (Mae) - 9-2-07

William (Bill) - 8-30-09

Catherine (Kay - 1-15-11

Lillian - 3-22-13

Eileen - 10-31-14

Bob - 12-24-17

Grandpa Patrick died in 1911. Annette was Godmother for Kay. Annette was also married about that time, as was Charlie. Later Annette would have a daughter, Eileen; Charlie a son, Jim.

Ralph spent a lot of time with Rob and Kitty and the young ones, with whom he was a big favorite. Of course he had to go in the Army 1st World War, Cavalry. He was honorably discharged and arrived home to Robs house on Christmas Eve, 1918.

While 1918 ended on a happy note for Rob and Kitty they were very saddened in October of that year when they learned that Charlie would not be returning from the Army as he had been buried in Bordeaux, France. Charlies son, Jim, was about five.

1919 was a wonderful year for those six kids of Rob & Kitty. Uncle Ralph lived near us, worked at the same print shop that Rob did and it was like having a delightful big brother around a lot to all the picnics, birthday parties, etc. Rob and Ralph rounded up between five and ten families every Sunday, they organized baseball teams, we all went swimming in Lake Michigan. Every Sunday in summer of course. In winter we all went skating on a lagoon only a few blocks away.

I dont remember the year Ralph married, but we were all thrilled with our new Aunt Sophie who now joined the summer picnics, the birthday parties, et al.

I remember very well, however, when Ralph and Sophies son was born because I was then close to 15. Ralph was still in the printing business but he and Sophie also ran a little neighborhood store and sometimes I had the unofficial title of clerk and could eat all the ice cream and other goodies I wanted.

They lived in back of the store in a neighborhood close to us so the baby, Ralph, was often wheeled over to our house and a darling child he was bright and happy, full of fun.

Now, for the tragedy, and it still breaks my heart. Young Ralph was very young about 3 when his mother died. I dont remember many of the details but I think Rob and his sister, Annette, decided Annette would take the baby temporarily until his father could make proper arrangements for caring for the child. About four, young Ralph traveled to New York put on the train in the care of the train personnel by Rob. Met at the train by Annette and husband, Jack.

Another tragedy! Ralph Sr. died not long after. Jr. was now adopted by the Gallaghers.

For a year or so, when Ralph was 9 or 10, Annette, Jack and Eileen lived in Chicago.

Time flies. Next thing we knew Ralph was in the service, returned home, was graduated from Georgetown, started to work, married Nancy, went to Texas, as I remember, in connection with his employment at Life.

Ralph was relocated to Chicago and I think he and Nancy had only Mary Annette at that time. We did not get out to see the family and they came in to see us with Mary, Peggy and Cathy. They moved from Park Forest to Glencoe (suburbs of Chicago) and Eileen and John were born before Ralph was relocated to New York.

Mary and Cathy you girls could finish the story as far as the Ralph Gallagher family is concerned. Youd know that much better than I would.

We saw your Dad only once in Chicago after he moved to New York with his young family that was when his Uncle Rob (sometimes known as Bob died). Ralph came to the funeral, as did Annette. Jack had died only a month or so before. Annette was looking forward to Robs visit to Florida. That was in April, 1961.

Of the Rob Cunningham family there are three left. Lillian, 74. Eileen 72 and me just turned 77.

We all look back with the fondest memories of our Aunts Annette and Mae and Uncle Ralph. Fond also, are our memories of their offspring your dad, your Aunt Eileen Croft and Jim Cunningham. Some of Robs children dont even remember Jims father who was our Uncle Charlie. I was seven when he came to say goodbye just before Christmas in 1917. His visits were just as much fun as the visits from Ralph your grandfather.

Your father was much loved by all of us, who were so much older then he was. We loved him for himself but we loved him also because Uncle Ralph and Aunt Sophie were his parents.

So now, some 130 years later, I must bring the story back to Rathmullen, County Sligo, Ireland. I have already written you about my visit there in the summer of 1986. I sat at the table where my grandmother had sat. Of course she was your fathers grandmother also. I felt proud and happy about my heritage and how privileged I was to have such parents and aunts and uncles as I did.

Your grandfather, Ralph and your father, Ralph, were very important in my life. My dad was one of a kind. I could never feel unhappy or blue about anything because almost everything reminds me of some saying of his that would make me laugh.

Enuf!Enuf! I have albums starting with a picture of my dad at age 3 with his brother, Charlie. If you ever get this way stop by and Ill be glad to show you the albums and tell you more about the delightful folks in Ireland, offspring of your Great Grandmother.

Lotsuvluv,

Kay

IrelandXO member

7 replies

Softdoor:

Welcome to Ireland Reaching Out!

Lovely letter!

Finding where your Curleys and Cunninghams came from in Sligo will be difficult because we don't have the parents names for Ellen and Patrick. I searched on Roots Ireland which is a subscription site and could not find any Ellen Curley baptismal records around 1855. There were many Patrick Cunningham baptismal records so no way to know which one might pertain to your ancestor.

Another issue is Rathmullen. There is no official townland in Co. Sligo called Rathmullen. Townland names were standarized around 1851 so Rathmullen is likely a local place name within a townland. I did go back to the 1830 Tithe records for Sligo and found a Rathmullen in Drumrat civil parish which is in south central Sligo and RC records for the parish start around 1842. However, I did not find any Curley or Cunningham baptismal records so a dead end. 

When I Googled Rathmullen Sligo, I got this real estate ad http://www.daft.ie/sligo/houses-for-sale/ballymote/bearvaish-rathmullen…;   The cottage for sale is in Bearvaish townland which turns out is in Drumrat civil parish. I also located this link https://www.logainm.ie/en/134458 ; which shows Rathmullen in Emlaghfad civil parish just north of Drumrat and a couple miles from the town of Ballymote. The Emlaghfad RC baptismal records start in July 1856 which is likely why I could not find a record for Ellen https://registers.nli.ie/parishes/0121

Did the letter writer, Kay, visit family in 1986?

Have you taken a autosomal DNA test?

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Dear Roger,
I am just so thrilled to hear back from someone. Thank you so much!!
First off I wanted to say that when I started my researching about a month ago I only found that Rathmullen was in County Donegal. So I was so confused about Aunt Kay saying she sat at the same table as my Great Grandmother in Rathmullen, County Sligo. Made me think I should really be searching in County Donegal. But I am so excited about the Rathmullen you have found in Sligo. This has all been very hard as we only have that one letter to go on and the letter Kay mentions that she wrote to my sisters about her trip in 1986 cannot be found. We (my siblings, 7 of us) all grew up thinking we were Gallagher's.  As you see in the letter my father's parents Ralph & Sophie died when he was about 3 - he was then adopted by his Aunt Annette Cunningham. So actually Cunningham & Curley are our real blood line. We always knew our ancestors were from Ireland though. Also there isn't anyone we know of that is alive that we can pick the brain of. Since I have just started the family tree on Ancetery.com I have been laying out everyone Kay mentions in the letter. I have not been able to find any marriage records for Ellen & Patrick in Boston yet. I have been very dedicated to it and have put in so many hours it's amazing - sometimes my eyes burn from so much screen time record hunting.
I am pretty sure Kay was visiting relatives in County Sligo but I just don't know for sure. She never say's in the letter that Patrick was from Sligo so that makes searching for him hard as well. I keep thinking maybe Ellen had a different name. I have been looking at what other name Ellen would be in Ireland.
I am working so hard on this because my youngest brother Charles is going to Ireland for the first time in June with his wife. He wants so badly to find out where we are from and to visit there. None of my other siblings have been to Ireland yet although it is our dream to go. I have had my brother take the DNA test on Ancestery.com and we are waiting for the results.I don't know if that is the same as what you called autosomal DNA test.
Just today I found a new place to search in Sligo for Curley's but it was a 1901 census - and Ellen left around 1880 or so. But there were Curley's in Sligo http://www.leitrim-roscommon.com/cgi-bin/newcen-srch
Someone on a Sligo page on Facebook gave this link saying some of the searches included sligo http://www.leitrim-roscommon.com/index.shtml
I know that I am searching for a needle in a haystack but I am dedicated to it. I am hoping we get the DNA results back before my brother leaves for Ireland.
Thank you so so so much for doing the searches you did. That's great that you found a "Rathmullen in Emlaghfad civil parish just north of Drumrat and a couple miles from the town of Ballymote" - that's exciting to me - I can't wait to tell that to my brother.
Thank you Roger for giving the care to me - that's what I call a true human - people that help make the world go round!!
My best to you,
Eeo
AKA Softdoor

IrelandXO member

Eeo:

The Ancestry test is autosomal which means it looks for matches on all maternal and paternal lines. 

The 1901 census site you located i my web site which I've had for almost twenty years.

The 1858 Griffiths Valuation head of household listing for Emlaghfad civil parish shows two Patrick Curleys in Cloonkeevy townland and a Patrick Cunningham in Ballymote town and a Winifred Cunningham in Carrigans Lower townland. Likely all have connections to you.  http://www.failteromhat.com/griffiths/sligo/emlaghfad.htm The Patrick Cunningham would not be the husband of Ellen for he would have been too young to be listed in the Griffiths.  http://www.failteromhat.com/griffiths/sligo/emlaghfad.htm

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Dearest Roger,

Oh that is so funny that I gave you a link to your own website!
I went back to it and surfed around and saw that you won the 2014 award!!
Congratulations for that - Makes total sense you should be awarded.
I read other peoples messages and I see you are just so helpful to so many!
So now on to the information you gave me in the message above..

I went and looked at the links you gave.
Now please excuse my naiveté - because I am very new to this - but when you say "Likely all have connections to you." What makes you say that?

I have been sharing our exchanges with my brother Charles who is so delighted.
He is going to look for a B&B or something in that area to stay for a few days.
I sent him a google map of Rathmullen in Sligo.

My best to you,
Eeo

IrelandXO member

Eeo:

I made the comment since your ancestors were from that area/parish and the surnames were Curley and Cunningham. Leap of faith but I'm confident. The tough part is proving/disproving my leap of faith.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Roger - I am sorry that I have not gotten back sooner. I am a great believer in Leaps of Faith...
Any suggestions on how I should proceed with this Leap?

Also any ideas on how I can find out more about Rathmullen in County Sligo? I have spent quite a bit of time looking and it seems it is literally a place, land, house?

https://www.google.com/maps/place/Rathmullen,+Co.+Sligo,+Ireland/@54.06…

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.