Back to Message Board

Elizabeth Irwin b. about 1789 in Ireland and moved to the USA

I'm looking for any info on Elizabeth Irwin who was born in Ireland. She is my 4x great-grandmother.According to US Census records she was born in Ireland around the year 1789. She married a man named William Williamson in 1816 in the US (marriedeither in Ohio or Pennsylvania) and died in Sycamore Township, Hamilton County, Ohio in 1858. Some clues have indicated she came to the US as a young teenager with her parents,althoughthis has not been verified.I have been unsuccessful in finding any info on her parents' namesor what county or parish she was from. Since I don't know her parents' names, I haven't been able to find any immigration records on this end in the US. Her name does not show up on any immigration records searches either. I have even hired professional geneologists to try to find this information. I was told there was a fire in Ireland that destroyed many emmigration records, which has made the search even more difficult. Any clues to her roots are greatly appreciated. Thanks!

IrelandXO member

5 replies

It’s true that there was a fire which destroyed a lot of Church of Ireland records, wills and other documents but it did not affect any emigration records, nor other denominations church records. The reality is that in the early 1800s there weren’t any emigration records in Ireland. (The authorities had no need to keep them, and so didn’t). Tracing someone who migrated at that era is notoriously difficult.

You don’t say what denomination your ancestor was but I’d hazard a guess she may have been Presbyterian. In which case that points to Scottish origins (probably family who settled in Ireland in the 1600s). She is likely to have lived in the counties of Ulster. You can see where the name is found across Ireland using this link. (Search under Erwin too as that is a common variant spelling).

http://www.irishtimes.com/ancestor/surname/

DNA testing might be the only way of finding any matches. That may of course also throw up matches in Scotland if that’s where the family originated, as is likely from the name.

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

 

Thank you, Elwyn, for your input.  I don't know what denomination she was.  My cousin in Ohio is supposed to be sending me some old books that belonged to a relative that just recently died at age 98.  I am hoping some of those old books of hers may have some info in them.  I will look into the Presbyterian possibility.  My dad did do the ancestry.com dna test, but I'm not sure if that links him to people outside of the US.  I'll have to ask the people at ancestry.com how to match with people abroad.  Should I have him do a test from an Ireland resource?  His dna test had him being 14% from Ireland and 32% from Great Britain.  I do believe you are correct about the Scottish roots of Erwin.  I will check out your link. At least the Ulster probability will give me a place to start.  Thanks again. 

 

 

IrelandXO member

There are 5 baptism records for Elizabeth Irwin 1789 + - 5 years on www.rootsireland.ie/:

The last 3 are 1787 & 1 is a repeat so perhaps you can eliminate them which brings it down to 2

Church BaptismErwinElizabeth1788Co. Westmeath
Church BaptismIrwinElizabeth1790Co. Down
Church BaptismErwinElizabeth1787Co. Dublin
Church BaptismErwinElizabeth1787Co. Dublin
Church BaptismErwinElizabeth Jane1787Co. Down

Name:Elizabeth ErwinDate of Birth:

Date of Baptism:28-Mar-1788Address:BallinvalleyParish/District:DELVINGender:FemaleCountyCo. Westmeath

Denomination:Roman Catholic
Father:William ErwinMother:Bridget KiernanOccupation:Not Recorded

Sponsor 1 /
Informant 1:John KiernanSponsor 2 /
Informant 2:Margaret Monaghan

Name:Elizabeth IrwinDate of Birth:

Date of Baptism:28-Sep-1790Address:CloghyParish/District:BALLYCULTERGender:FemaleCountyCo. Down

Denomination:Church of Ireland
Father:Hugh IrwinMother:Ann

Col

ColCaffIrelandXO Volunteer

Thanks very much Col!  Some definite good clues!

IrelandXO member

Re DNA testing what you find is that far more people in the US get tested than anywhere else and consequently get lots of matches with each other. Comparatively few people in Ireland get DNA tested. Most aren’t interested and some are a bit suspicious of it, and so there are not that many samples for the American samples to be tested against. That’s why it’s hard to get a match with anyone on this side of the pond. Most of the reputable companies should be testing against their complete database and you shouldn’t have to ask for a comparison with Irish samples.

 

I’d be a bit cautious about some of the claimed results. There’s no such thing as an Irish, Scottish, Welsh or British gene, as some commercial companies claim (based on very small samples in some cases). The people of these islands moved around a lot over the years. The vast majority all share common Brythonic origins topped up with some Saxon and Viking influences. They all overlap massively. Huge numbers of Scots settled in Ireland for example, and literally millions of Irish people have settled in England. The DNA picture is complex.

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.