Back to Message Board

Deffley and Cunningham

Seeking parish/birth information on PATRICK DEFFLEY, born in Connaught (likely Leitrim or Roscommon) in approximately 1811-1814 to John and Anne Deffley. Patrick was married to CATHERINE CUNNINGHAM.

Patrick died in Providence, Rhode Island on March 28, 1892. Catherine died in Providence on April 23, 1897. Among the children of Patrick and Catherine Deffley were James E., Patrick, Michael, Mary, John, Francis (Frank), Thomas, and Herbert (or Hubert) Deffley. In the mid- to late 19th century this family lived in US localities such as Owego, New York; Rush Township, Pennsylvania; New London, Connecticut; Smithfield, RI; and finally Providence.

Patrick and Catherine's grandchlldren included Joseph, Andrew J., Thomas, Anna, George D., Ernest, and Stephen Deffley. Many of the Deffleys worked in woolen/worsted mills. Thomas Deffley worked alternatively as a textile worker, boilermaker, and teamster.

James E. Deffley and his nephew Andrew J. Deffley worked for US railroads. James E. was a railway shop blacksmith in Connecticut, while Andrew progressed from blacksmith to locomotive fireman (on the Delaware & Hudson RR out of Oneonta, NY); to locomotive engineer on the Wabash Cannonball in Illinois.

Many thanks to anyone who can help in this search.

IrelandXO member

10 replies

Dave:

Based on data from the 1857 Griffiths Valuation, Patrick likely came from Mohill civil parish in Co. Leitrim. Deffley was not a common surname and almost all the Deffleys in the Griffiths came from Mohill. I also looked at the 1834 Tithe Applotment listing with the same results --Mohill parish. See below.

RC church records for Mohill start in 1836. Did Patrick and catherine marry in Ireland and were any children born in Ireland?

Roger McDonnell

Surname Forename Townland/Street Parish County Year
Deffley Conner Acres Mohill Leitrim, Longford 1834
Deffley Michl Clooneene Mohill Leitrim, Longford 1834
Deffley Peter Gortnalamph Mohill Leitrim, Longford 1834
Deffley James Gortnalamph Mohill Leitrim, Longford 1834
 
Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Roger:

Thanks for the prompt response. In return, I’m sending you a long message. Have a happy New Year!

--Dave

----------------------------------------------------------------

I only had the word of my grandmother, the wife of Joseph Deffley (a grandson of Patrick), that the family came from Leitrim. So your findings regarding Mohill do make sense.

I don’t believe that Patrick and Catherine Deffley were married in Ireland or that their children were born there. That said, I only have the word of the oldest son, James Edward—if he was indeed Patrick’s son--that he was born in Owego, New York.

About Owego : The New York and Erie Railroad was completed to Owego in 1849, where the Erie built its bridge shop. Two hundred workers there built new wooden bridges and repaired old ones. The Irish first arrived to drive wooden piles for the railroad. When the railroad was completed, many Irish laborers decided to remain in Owego permanently. Early meetings for Catholic services were held at the home of David Connelly on Paige Street.

The first U.S. census record I’ve found for the Deffleys in Owego in 1850 :

- Patrick Defley, age 36, M, laborer, born Ireland

-Catherine Defley, age 25, F, born Ireland

-Michael Defley, age 3, M, born New York

-John Defley, age 1, M, born Pennsylvania.

-Francis Defley, age 2 months, born Pennsylvania.

St. Patrick’s Church (Owego) pastors: Rev. James F. Hourigan (1832-1842), Rev. John J. Sheridan (1844-1850), James McManus (age 32 in the 1855 census) and Rev. James V. O’Reilly—later, in 1842, made pastor of the church in Friendsville, PA. Other priests were Fathers Burns, Creedon, Mallon, McManus, Butler, Corning, Clark, Rogers, O’Mara, Johnson, and Ryan.

The Owego census, first election district, June 4, 1855 lists names such as Kelly, Featherstone, Quinn, Foley (James), Reynolds, Costello, Hanley (Mary, 40), Neal, Connor, McCormick, Cunningham, and McManus (Fr. James and his brother Michael. A common occupation: “laborer, RR.” The second election district lists names such as Phineas Creagan (35, farmer) and Harriet Cragan (27, wife).

A number of Irish families were encouraged to settle in the Middletown and Rush areas of Susquehanna County, PA, as early as 1829, by Irishman Edward White and his principal, Dr. D.H. Rose, who owned much land in the area. The first Irish settler, David Hillis, came in 1836, followed by Messrs. Carroll in 1839, P. Redding in 1841, and James Logan in 1842.

The Catholic Chapel, near Bixby’s Pond, was built about 1859 under the direction of Father O’Reilly, at “that time the priest at St. Joseph.” This frame building, formerly part of the William Golden farm, served Catholics from the northern part of Rush and the southern part of Middletown, and was part of the Friendsville parish.

Another historical version: St. Patrick’s Church in Middletown was built in 1858 “under the leadership of the Very Rev. J.V. O’Reilly, the great apostle of catholicity in northeastern Pennsylvania. The land and adjoining cemetery were given to the parish by William Golden, one of the pioneer Catholics in the area.” The church rector in 1960 was the Rev. Donald W. Fallon.

Here’s the first complete record of the Patrick and Catherine Deffley household, taken from the 1880 U.S. census in Providence, Rhode Island :

-Patrick Deffly, age 65, laborer, unemployed 8 months, born Ireland

-Catherine Deffly, age 54, wife, keeping house, b. Ireland

-Michael Deffly, age 32, son, weaver in woolen mill, b. New York

-Catherine Deffly, age 27, daughter-in-law, keeping house, b. Ireland

-Frank Deffly, age 28, son, woolen weaver, b. New York

-Kate Deffly, age 24, daughter-in-law, keeping house, b. New York

-Thomas Deffly, age 23, son, woolen weaver, b. Pennsylvania

-Herbert Deffly, age 20, son, works in woolen mill, b. Pennsylvania

-Mary Deffly, age 19, daughter, works in woolen mill, b. Pennsylvania

-Joseph Wolfheart, age 23, boarder, woolen weaver, b. Bavaria

-Mary Deffly, 8/12, granddaughter, b. Rhode Island

-Ann McLeann, age 55, keeping house, b. Ireland

-Mary J. Gormley, age 36, boarder, works in delaine mill, b. Ireland (native of Leitrim).

-Frank Gormley, age 4, attending school, born Ireland.

(I believe these Gornley tenants had a Leitrim connection: from Ballinamore. )

Other Almira Street neighbors included Grady; McGuinness; Holland, Helen and Catherine Smith and their boarder Luke Hanley (age 29, carpenter); Lenahan, and Bligh.

Buried near Patrick and Catherine Deffley in St. Francis Cemetery, Pawtucke aret :

-Ellen Fagan, born 1865, died August 27,1889. Parish of Aughavass, Co. Leitrim.

-James D. Walsh and Ellen Ryan Walsh.

-McGurn/Rooney/O’Connor.

- John J. O’Connor, died October 9, 1893 at 62 years. Mary, his wife, died August 22, 1883 at 52 years.

-Peter J. Hanley, 1856-1939 (another date on stone: 1813-1888).

-Thomas Hanley/Margaret Dolan.

-Ann Brennan, 1819-1883.

-Stewart.

-Finn/Martin.

-John and Mary Fallon.

-Neary.

-James Dyer, Whitehall, Sligo.

-Patrick O’Connell, Cork.

-CANNING?(#448) ?John Canning, 1830 - 1899?. Margaret, his wife, 1836-1888. ?Natives of Ballinamore, Co. Leitrim, Ireland. Rest in peace. ?(side) ?Thomas H., 1858 -1915. ?Mary A., 1860 -1927. ?Patrick F., 1856 -1931. ?Katherine L., 1873 -1936. ?(side)? Sarah J., wife of James B. Canning, 1865-1894. ?Christopher J., 1892 -1894.  ?James B., 1892 -1894.?

 

IrelandXO member

Dave:

Happy New Year to you also!

I enjoyed reading your family history. I think that Patrick and Catherine were married in New York State since I did not find their marriage on Roots Ireland indexes. They likely emigrated separately during the famine.

Since Michael was Patrick's oldest son, I'm wondering if Michael was the name of his father. You will note that one of the four Deffleys in the Tithes was a Michael. The townland was transcribed as Clooneene but when you look at the microfilm of the record, it was actually Clooncene. In any event, that name went away when they standardized townland names around 1850. From looking at the 1857 Griffiths for Mohill parish, I'm going to make an educated guess that the townland became Corracramph South. The 1834 Tithes showed four Cox entries in the townland including a Francis and Thomas. Those two show up in the 1857 Griffiths in Cooracramph South.

Roger

http://www.failteromhat.com/griffiths/leitrim/mohill.htm

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Roger:

If your hunch about Corracramph South shows up, that leads me pretty close to the Roscommon line. I’ve followed the Ballykilcline Society’s work on the 1847 eviction of families from the Ballykilcline townland in Kilglass Parish, Roscommon. The list of evictees includes two Deffley households, and I’ve seen a Patt and James Deffley listed in 1833 tax records for Kilglass and Elphin, Roscommon

But the only county name I ever heard from a relative was Leitrim. I’m fascinated by the mention, especially, of a Francis and Thomas Deffley in Clooncene. In the 1900 U.S. census for Long Beach, CA here were the children of Francis (Frank) Deffley, son of Patrick and Catherine: Frank, Julia, Hubert, Johnnie, Kate, and Alice.

The children of my great grandfather, Thomas Deffley, included Joseph (my grandfather), Andrew, Thomas, Ernest, Anna, John H, Stephen, and George D.A.

I agree that Patrick and Catherine Deffley were most likely married in the U.S.

Thanks again for your (prompt) digging.  I feel closder to learning a much more about our Deffley origins. 

--Dave 

IrelandXO member

Roger:

You noted above: "Since Michael was Patrick's oldest son, I'm wondering if Michael was the name of his father."

I can't honestly answer that. I only have this cemetery record to go by:

"Patrick Deffley, age 81, 15 days, died March 28, 1892, Coal [miner?], 124 Putnam St., Providence. Born Ireland, parents: John and Ann. Causes of death: bronchial asthma, old age."

Thanks again for your questions and help!

--Dave

IrelandXO member

Roger:

You noted above: "Since Michael was Patrick's oldest son, I'm wondering if Michael was the name of his father."

I can't honestly answer that. I only have this cemetery record to go by:

"Patrick Deffley, age 81, 15 days, died March 28, 1892, Coal [miner?], 124 Putnam St., Providence. Born Ireland, parents: John and Ann. Causes of death: bronchial asthma, old age."

Thanks again for your questions and help!

--Dave

IrelandXO member

Roger:

You noted above: "Since Michael was Patrick's oldest son, I'm wondering if Michael was the name of his father."

I can't honestly answer that. I only have this cemetery record to go by:

"Patrick Deffley, age 81, 15 days, died March 28, 1892, Coal [miner?], 124 Putnam St., Providence. Born Ireland, parents: John and Ann. Causes of death: bronchial asthma, old age."

Thanks again for your questions and help!

--Dave

IrelandXO member

Dave:

If John was Patrick's fathers name then forget about my theory leading to Corracramph South.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Roger: 

I'm aware that Irish immigrants sometimes interchanged their first and middle names in records. But even in this case I note that the head of household went by "John" in the New London census of 1870.

1870 U.S. Census, Groton (New London County), CT, June 25, 1870

-John Deffley, 56, farm laborer, born Ireland.

-James Deffley, 16, works in woolen mill, born New York.

-Thos. Deffley, 14, works in woolen mill, born New York.

-Patrick Deffley, 12, work in woolen mill, born Pennsylvania

-Herbert Deffley, 10, works in woolen mill, born Pennsylvania.

-Mary A. Deffley, 10, born Pennsylvania.

-Catherine Deffley, 45, washerwoman, born Ireland.

Meanwhile, the 1870 census found this guy in Ledyard, CT (P.0. Mystic Rver):

- Patrick Deffley, 54, farm laborer, born Ireland. Estimated birth year: 1815

Enough mystery for now. Thanks, though, for all your help!

--Dave

 

 

 

 

 

IrelandXO member

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.