Back to Message Board

CROSKERY / DICKSON MYSTERY: PLEASE HELP

Please help solve my family’s greatest mystery! I’ve been working on this line for 18 years and I’m potentially traveling to Ireland this August, 2025 (so please provide your recommendations where to research) and any leads or information you can share with me to solve this. I need a marriage a document to go any further or a birth/baptism record of William.

They were PRESBYTERIAN

Thomas Croskery (different variants of spelling): Born about 1823 (possibly in Northern Ireland) married about 1849:

Jane Dickson (or Dixson) born about 1820 in Ireland

They had one son in Ireland:

William Croskery born March 23, 1850 (possibly in Belfast)

They all immigrated to Canada (probably through the USA) around 1852 (I cannot find them in any ship passenger lists or border crossings).

I have all the Canadian records (Census, death certificates etc) ensuring they were real people, so I’m good on this side.

Thomas might have been a cordwain (shoemaker); however I’m not entirely sure.

I have tried Ancestry.com $, Roots Ireland $ and various other sites without luck. I have also sent requests in to PRONI without any documents found.

I understand there is also a well established Croskery line that immigrated to the USA. This is not my line. Please reach out if you have any suggestions! Thank you. shaughnessyk (at) yahoo.ca

Thank you for any suggestions!

shaughnessyk@y…

10 replies

Marriage cert for a Thomas Croskery and Mary Emily Dixon 1861 . He is a Minister (Presbyterian) in Creggan, Belfast.

kellyeileen20@…

The above couple did have a son William born 1867

kellyeileen20@…

Thank you, but they were living in Canada in 1852 so that can't be them. They had William in 1850 in Ireland (according to his marriage and death certificate) and they immigrated to Canada in about 1852 and proceeded to have multiple children. This Census (see attachment) shows Thomas, Jane, William etc. in 1861 living in Montague, Lanark, Canada West (Ontario)

Here is William's marriage certificate indicating he was born in Ireland and was 23 yrs old at the time of his marriage in Ontario Canada in 1873. This also lists Thomas and Jane as his parents.

shaughnessyk@y…

shaughnessyk:

The surname Croskery was almost exclusively found in Co. Down in the mid-19th century which would support your Northern Ireland location.

From 1845 on, non Roman Catholic marriages were to be civilly registered. However, I could not find a record which likely means they failed to register the marriage.

Looking at the index of Presbyterian records for Co. Down on the subscription site Roots Ireland, many of the parishes have records starting later than 1850.

Have you taken a general DNA test which might provide matches on your Croskery/Dickson line?

I will make sure our Northern Ireland expert sees this message and possibly he will have some suggestions.

Roger McDonnell

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Thank you Roger! I have taken an Ancestry DNA test. Should I take a another kind? Thank you again for your suggestions and your attention. -Karlie

shaughnessyk@y…

Karlie:

Your Ancestry test works. Hopefully, you have some matches on this line.

Roger

Castlemore RoscommonIrelandXO Volunteer

Karlie,

Birth registration didn’t start in Ireland till 1864 so you won’t find a birth certificate for William b c 1850. You might find his baptism but to do that you would need to know precisely where he was born. Not all church records have survived and of those that do still exist, not all are on-line as you probably know.  I take his religious denomination to be UP ie United Presbyterian. If he was born in Belfast there are about 25 Presbyterian churches in the city with records for the 1850s. You say you have been in touch with PRONI and they cannot find anything. That perhaps suggests he was born outside Belfast or that if born in Belfast, the relevant church has no records for that period. There are perhaps 400 Presbyterian churches in Northern Ireland, so if you don’t know where he lived, it’s a needle in a haystack.

Protestant marriage records started on 1st April 1845. There’s no sign of the couple’s marriage in Ireland 1845 - 1852, so perhaps they married before that? In which case, if they exist,  the records are probably not on-line.

As has been suggested, possibly DNA testing may be a way of matching with others who have additional information about where the family originate. Family Tree DNA reportedly has more people with Ulster roots than any other company. That obviously increases the chances of finding a match. You might want to try them or, if you have already tested, you can transfer your results to them for no fee.

The North of Ireland Family History Society is running an Ulster DNA project.  http://www.nifhs.org (Go to DNA project on the website).

Elwyn, IrelandXO Volunteer ☘IrelandXO Volunteer

Hi Karlie,

Croskery was associated with Inch Abby. The Family are celtic descent with Scithian a nomadic people ( Modern Day Ukrain )

I enclose a book for you to read . scroll to the bottom and read each page on the way back up :)

hopefully this may help with your search.

The family story claims a link to 

Taxman

Thank you. I have read it multiple times in the past and just visited Inch Abbey and region this August.. How do you know the Croskerys are from celtic descent with Scithian a nomadic people? Can you share your source for this? :)

Karlie

shaughnessyk@y…

Other than DNA, Thomas himself recounts the oral history as going back around 2000 years . how accurate it is I dont know.

Our DNA clearly shows Scythian and Viking  as well as Celt, Pict from the Ireland and Scottish area.

So at some point in our past there was a joining of different peoples. 

https://paganheim.com/blogs/culture-religion/the-scythian-origin-theory-of-the-irish-people-myth-or-historical-reality?srsltid=AfmBOooLndqBxhcryDU3Y_UnDqoNey5Uqsu1QlXieomXjBdtvmo9M8Ti

I am reminded that the city of Troy was thought to be just a legend until they actualy found it.  That coupled with the legends and Myths associated with Ireland give me hope that perhaps some small part is true.

Good luck with your search !

Ian R Smith

Taxman

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.