Roger,
Many thanks for your reply and information.
Internet Surname Base lists Crolly Crawley, Crawley,Croely,and Crawlyas variations of Crolly. The record you have found is a baptism but how old was the child?
The First Catherine arriving on Thomas Arbuthnot NP is Cork age 19
Second Catherine arriving on James Fernie lists NP as Dublin age 18
It is now a toss up. I am leaning towards the one from Dublin.
Catherine a housemaid on arrival was engaged by Mrs Fitzgerald of 29 Little Oxford St for 6 weeks.
If this is our girl the next time we find her is 250 miles away at Lindenow East Gippsland married to John Henry Vincent. 1859. Rgd is 1860/289. It was probably registered much later. as this was remote country and the main Police district was at Sale.
She was widowed the same year 1859 when John was killed in fall from horse. Inq 1227/1859 in Sale district.
From her personal story related in later years to her daughter in law Grace she was 3 mths pregnant when she travelled the 200 odd miles to Cheltenham, walking most of the way. She met her future second husband Elias Hayes a widower with 4 children and a market gardener,,at an employment agency at Cheltenham. Elias employed her and one month after the birth of her baby they were married and had seven children . She was married to Elias as Catherine Mary Vincent 24th June 1860 Isabella Vincent was reared as their eldest child and later married Oliver Johnson in Melbourne.
How or why she went to East Gippsland we have no idea. Probably by ship to Sale and then overland 60 miles by bullock wagon. Roads were non existent then as Melbourne had only been a European settlement since 1835.
I suspect that as she was a housemaid employed on short term she probably went to an employment agency and obtained a position with a property owner at Lindenow, who would have paid her travel costs if she stayed for a certain time. Here she met and married John Vincent and upon his death had no further reason to stay so returned to the city.
Elias was a good man and a succesful Market gardener. Catherine's life had turned out well for her. Elias died in 1891 and she lived until 1914.
Any suggestions as to where to go from here will be appreciated.