Cullybackey is a separate parish about 5 miles from Ahoghill and since 1728 has had its own Presbyterian church. (It also had a United Presbyterian Church and still has a Reformed Presbyterian church. Neither of them existed in the 1700s though). You are correct that Cullybackey Presbyterian has records of baptisms for the 1700s. It’s the only church in that part of Antrim that does have 18th century records. But if your family lived in Ahoghill they are most likely to have attended there, not in Cullybackey, and sadly no records exist for any of them for the 1700s.
Looking at the current local phone book for Co Antrim, I see about 130 Carsons listed. (There will obviously be more as many people are not listed these days). If you send me your e-mail address, I can send you a copy, and you can contact them. I would just say that you may need to manage your expectations. In my experience, few people here would know their family history back more than about 3 generations (ie to around 1900) and you may struggle to find many who know their ancestors in the 1750s.
You could also contact the Ballymena Branch of the North of Ireland Family History Society (NIFHS) to see if anyone there knows of your family. Or you could put a message in “North Irish Roots” the NIFHS journal asking for information. (That’s free). http://www.nifhs.org