2 replies
Thanks very much for your quick response. I did already know the details you give having researched my family history a few years ago where amongst other sources I hired Irish genealogist and Cork specialist Dr Paul MacCotter with a main task of establishing Caesar Fanning's parents. He came up with much info on Caesar Fanning and his family but nothing on his parentage. Caesar apparently had sons who carried on the family paper staining and later their house painting business into which they diversified when mechanical printing of wall paper was introduced in the mid 19th century rendering the original "paper staining" hand printed wall paper trade obsolete. I'm descended from one of Caesar's sons , William Fanning born 1785 , who moved to England permanently shortly after graduating from Trinity College Dublin in 1807.
The specific puzzle to solve was that it had always been claimed in my family from several generations back that Caesar was a brother to noted colonial administrator , Edmund Fanning , who was born in America , along with all his siblings , to American born parents. After trawling up all the evidence I could from a wide variety of source material I came to the conclusion that although extremely unlikely this brother relationship was true , there was still a glimmer of possibility due to Edmund Fanning's mother having died in 1750 aged 48 on the return journey from England to America - if she had been in England then may also have been in Ireland where she could have given birth to Caesar. Establishing his parentage would solve the puzzle and having failed with a professional genealogical research attempt , I'm going for a last ditch effort to seek out descendants of Caesar who may have knowledge of his parentage !
Indeed , these were my immediate thoughts also. There could also be other possible scenarios , for instance , Edmund's mother (Hannah , nee Smith) could have been visiting family members in Ireland where she gave birth and with whom she left her new baby to be raised after falling ill and trying to return to her immediate family in America. Hannah's husband was a Capt. James Fanning , grandson of the original immigrant to the American colonies , Edmund Fanning Snr , who settled in Connecticut in 1653 following confiscation of family lands in Limerick by Oliver Cromwell. The American family branch history is well recorded in Walter Frederic Brooks' meticulously researched history in 825 pages "History of the Fanning Family" that covers the ten generations from 1653 to 1900 , privately published in 210 copies , Worcester , Massachusetts,1905. Brooks' mother was a Fanning. There's a copy of a complete original book available online. No mention of a Caesar under Capt. James Fanning's children , all eleven of which being born in Suffolk county , New York. Son Edmund Fanning was one of a twin born 1739 and the last recorded birth in Brooks' history. I have since found record of a 12th child , a daughter Sally , in 1743 on Wikitree but no reference to where she was born. So grey areas remain in the research but afraid I may have now hit a pretty solid brick wall. Other than the family folklore the only documentary evidence I have showing a brother relationship between Caesar and Edmund is a formal family tree compiled with professional help from Burke's Landed Gentry in 1950 by a Fanning family member in our Australian branch who died in 1954 and whose descendants cannot come up with the source material for his claim. Burke's entry for my Fanning family in their 18th edition (1972) goes back to Caesar as the first recorded family member but nothing on his parents. Don't know in which Cork parish Caesar's birth was recorded - he was Church of Ireland - so nowhere to check there and of course the cenralised Church of Ireland records were lost in the 1922 fire at the Public Records Office in Dublin. Will keep searching for a descendant of Caesar's who may have the missing piece in the puzzle. Many thanks for your comments and interest.
