Back to Message Board

Baptism puzzle Strokestown and New Ross

I am trying to find out more about my 3x great grandmother, Maria Cullen, b. about 1801m married Michael Carey in May 1823, in Stepney, London. She was in London when their first (known) child was born in about 1828, and in censuses her birth is simply given as Ireland. I have found on Ancestry a possible baptism, but the same information appears twice in two different places: daughter of Petri Cullen and Anastasia Whelan, b. March 12th 1801, baptised March 13th 1801, sponsors Gualterius Lawler and Catherina Moran. However, one is in Strokestown, diocese Elphin, Roscommon, the other in New Ross, Ferns diocese, Wexford. How can this be? Has Ancestry got its documents mixed up?

janetawhit@aol.com

2 replies

I dont see how it can be a genuine RC baptism record for the parish of Strokestown/Kiltrustan and Bumlin as their records only go back to 1830. There is a baptism matching the details you mention in the records for New Ross RC parish (NLI RC registers) with the name as "Mariam Cullin", however I would treat this as just a possible match to your Maria/Mary without further evidence from later sources - e.g. a detailed place of birth or parents names. Very few Catholic parishes have records going back this far so it's quite likely that there is no record available of her baptism.

p.s. a few years ago, before the NLI register images were available online, I came across other records like this on Ancestry with the incorrect parish assignments in one of their 'Transcript only' collections - I informed them, but I dont believe these were fixed.

shanew147IrelandXO Volunteer

Thank you, Shanew.  I really didn't see how it could be humanly possible to have a ceremony in one place then nip across the country for another one.  One of the reports in Ancestry is simply a transcription, the other has the digitised parish record - but the name of the parish , or even the town, is on it. I can find nothing that can definitely identify the parents of Maria Cullin or her place of birth, but thought I'd work on the adults in the baptism record to see where that leads. The only tiny glimmer is that Walter (Gualterius) is a family name in each generation. On the other hand, AncestryDNA estimates my ethnicity as 25% Irish - Connacht. I'll probably never know!

janetawhit@aol.com

Reply

Reply
One image file up to 2 MB.